Massachusetts Institute of Technology - Department of Urban Studies and Planning


11.188: Urban Planning and Social Science Laboratory

Project Titles and Abstracts - Spring 2019


MONDAY PRESENTATIONS (May 13, Room W31-301, 2:30-5:00 PM)


Name Title Abstract
1 Braxton Bridgers “Cancer Alley: Mapping Vulnerabilities of Populations Within Louisiana's Infamous Chemical Corridor” In Louisiana, there is an industrial corridor which spans 85 miles, from New Orleans to Baton Rouge. Infamously referred to as Cancer Alley, this industrial corridor has become a cause for concern amongst environmental and social justice activists, in large part due to reported cases of illnesses (such as cancer) that are disportionate to other areas across the U.S. This study seeks to both map the profile of communities residing within the industrial corridor and examine the vulnerabilities of these populations by visualizing socioeconomic data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (ACS): median household income, unemployment rates, poverty levels, educational attainment and ethnicity. These indicators will be joined to U.S. census block group shapefiles in order to establish descriptive statistics. Additionally, the toxicity of the 100 plus industrial and chemical facilities within Cancer Alley will be identified and visualized utilizing Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Risk Screening Environmental Indicator (RSEI) data, in order to highlight communities that are especially vulnerable due to their proximity to highly toxic facilities. A “danger zone” buffer will be established for facilities according to EPA health and environmental buffer standards.
2

 

Katie Fisher

Take a Hike: Comparing Access to Hiking Trails in Boston and Seattle



Many residents of cities enjoy the easy access to infrastructure and other amenities, but still might want to spend time hiking during their free time. For this project, I will look at access to hiking trails from urban areas. More specifically, how many hiking trails can be accessed from different cities? This project will evaluate access in terms of car and by public transportation. I will compare access to hiking trails from Boston and Seattle using a website called The Hiking Project which hosts a crowdsourced database of trails. I will then measure two different factors of accessibility. I will do a street network analysis to determine how long it takes to drive to those trails from the center of Boston or Seattle. I will then use commuter rail, T and bus stop shapefile to determine how many hiking trails are accessible by public transportation, for those without a car. The dataset also contains information on trail length and difficulty, allowing additional analysis of type types of trails accessible from each city.
3 Hadley Piper The Legacies of Louisville’s First Master Plan: 1930 Zoning, 2010 outcomes

 

In 1917 the supreme court heard Buchanan vs Warley, in which a black man sued to live in a house he owned, an act which was outlawed by Louisville’s Racial zoning ordinance. The supreme court found Louisville’s racial zoning ordinance unconstitutional, outlawing overtly race-based zoning in America. The 1930 Louisville Comprehensive plan and zoning regulations sought to replace racial zoning with a new, legal method of implementing segregation:, identifying areas populated or likely to be populated by black resident, and designating these areas as industrial, with the intention of replacing “slum housing” in these areas with institutional state-managed housing, while protecting white neighborhoods with restrictive single family designations, preventing the migration of lower income, black, and ethnic residents from “degrading” these neighborhoods. Nearly 90 years later, many of the same development pattern from 1930 persist, but the city has also changed drastically, with its limits expanding to contain nearly 3x the land area contained in 1930. This project highlights development and demographic trends and compares them to the original 1930 zoning scheme. Vacant property, foreclosures, land use, contemporary zoning, racial makeup, income, housing tenure are all compared to the original zoning scheme, with the intent to demonstrate both the lasting impact of Louisville’s first master plan, as well as unforeseen trends and growth the occured throughout the 20th century.
4 Meital Hoffman From Arrests to Sentences: Cannabis Possession in Chicago

The Illinois legislature is expected to vote on a bill legalizing recreational marijuana in the coming months, potentially making cannabis possession legal. For now, however, thousands of Chicago residents are arrested for cannabis possession and tens are sent to jail each year. Using Chicago PD arrest data from the Chicago Open Data Portal and ACS demographic measures, I will explore where most marijuana possession arrests are occuring in the city and how they compare to racial and economic factors. I am also using data from the Cook County Open Data portal to analyze sentencing for cannabis possession. I am focussing on 2018 to ensure that my conclusions are relevant and up-to-date with current cannabis legislation. My results will highlight communities that are unjustly targeted in arrests and sentencing. Along with choropleth maps, I will include necessary graphs and tables to highlight my findings. From initial exploration it is clear that mostly black men are sentenced for marijuana possession and sentence severity varies greatly depending on the judge. While legalization is a step forward in ending the unjust “War on Drugs” started in the 1970s, reflection and reparations are crucial to understanding the longstanding effects of biased policing and sentencing.
5 James Li A Tool for Evaluating Street-Scale Walkability Using R and Google Maps

The experience of being a pedestrian can be frustrating and difficult when street systems are not designed with pedestrians in mind – for example, when crossing the road legally requires detouring some distance to get to the nearest crosswalk. Existing “walkability” metrics such as the Walk Score (https://www.walkscore.com/) tend to measure “walkability” in terms of access to amenities such as restaurants and schools. In this project, I examine “walkability” at a more fundamental and granular level: For a given point, how much unnecessary distance is needed to walk to nearby points?

This project focuses on the development of an R script that uses the igraph library and OpenAddresses data to build a graph of addresses across the city with each address connected to its neighbors. The script queries the Google Maps Directions API for walking distance data, and then calculates a metric of walkability by comparing the actual walking distances to the straight-line distances for each address. The resulting map highlights regions of better or worse pedestrian convenience and may be useful as a tool for building a more complete understanding of walkability.


WEDNESDAY PRESENTATIONS (May 15, Room 9-255, 2:30-5:00 PM)


Name
Title
Abstract
1 Sean Robins Transit-Oriented Commercial Development Opportunties

2 Jennifer Fox Renewable Energy Saturation Based on Estimated Potentials The question my project seeks to satisfy surrounding distinguishing an optimal method for measuring the saturation of installed renewable energy infrastructure based on different calculated potentials. Searching through available online data sets, I decided to focus on two main comparisons: the first cartographic display, US Turbine Density & Wind Potential, and the second, State Renewable Energy & PV Potential. The first map uses data from three sources: the United States Wind Turbine Database 2018, ArcGIS Hub Countries WGS84, and Global Wind Atlas’s (GWA) Mean Wind Power Densities at 50m Elevation. The purpose of the map is to contrast the number of major installed wind turbines around the United States (in units per hectare) normalized against spatial area with calculated potential for energy production. GWA calculated the potential as a mean wind power density measured at 50 meter elevation. I first exported a polygon of the US using Select by Attribute from the downloaded world country dataset. As GWA provides this potential as a .tif file covering all of North America, I clipped the raster using ArcToolbox(Data Management > Raster > Raster Processing > Clip) against the new US polygon. Next, I worked on illustrating where the majority of installed turbines exist using circular point density analysis, classifying by quantiles and layering at the highest level with 50% transparency to produce the final map. The second map uses four data sources: National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), Direct Normal Irradiation (DNI) 10-km Resolution 1998-2012, ArcGIS Hub USA States 2018 WGS84, US Department of Energy, State Energy Data System 2016, and the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s (EIA) State Energy Data System’s (SEDA) production estimates, renew_prod_2009.csv . This map’s purpose is to contrast national potential for photovoltaic output with calculated renewable energy production scaled based on annual state ranking. NREL calculates potential based on annual solar resources averaged over surface cells approximately 10 kilometers in size. I chose to juxtapose this average with state rankings to examine saturation of renewable energy production based off of potential and current relative energy practices. To do this, I intersected the US photovoltaic potential file (which extended into offshore zones surrounding the mainland lower 48) with USA States 2018. I then joined the CSV with the renewable energy production state rankings to the ArcGIS polygon on a basis of state name. To classify by state ranking, I used Graduated Symbols for the Symbology valued by solar_prod , with zero normalization and five quantile classification. Moving forward for both maps, I intend to draw conclusions by approximating values from the rasters, normalizing wind turbine and renewable energy production estimates against calculated potentials to place value on the clean energy saturation these areas display relative to other American regions. For the second map, I also seek to find a method to approximate solar penetration while taking into account the percent of renewable energy produced by photovoltaics per state, relative to other non-conventional resources.

3 Lydia Gramstad

Exploring Revitalization of Neighborhoods in Birmingham, Alabama

Like many US cities, Birmingham, Alabama experienced a “white flight” to the suburbs in the 1960s and has been struggling to achieve an occupied and thriving downtown area since then. In recent years, two neighborhoods have attracted attention for their apparent neighborhood revitalization. Historically, Avondale has been a working-class neighborhood near an industrial area, and Norwood was built as a community for more affluent residents. The neighborhoods abut each other, with Norwood to the northeast of Birmingham’s central business district and Avondale to the east of it. Both were formed in the early 1900s and many existing structures date back to that time. Scores of residences in both neighborhoods have stood abandoned and dilapidated for years. Visiting the neighborhoods provides significant physical evidence of revitalization as many historic residences have been or are currently being renovated or restored. However, a visit cannot provide comprehensive understanding of the economic and social factors at play. While improvements to structures are naturally celebrated, the mere presence of improvements gives minimal indication of the nature of changes occurring in an area, particularly regarding demographics of residents.

 

Through a comparison of 2000, 2010, and 2017 census data and thematic mapping of census tracts and block groups for Avondale and Norwood and Birmingham as a whole, these areas can be studied more analytically and quantitatively, potentially producing a practical and functional report for the area. While innumerable factors could be analyzed, relevant economic statistics include changes in vacancy, rent, housing value, and income, and relevant social statistics include changes in residency, racial makeup, median age, and poverty. These statistics contextualize the two neighborhoods in comparison to Birmingham over the past two decades, revealing similarities and disparities between each of them. In some ways, Avondale and Norwood have developed similarly to the rest of the city. However, for many factors, they have developed in notably different ways, some of which may be considered as favorable and others as unfavorable, depending on perspective. Overall, the data indicates that there have been changes to the neighborhoods as a reduction in black residents corresponded to an influx of white residents and an increase in housing costs. What remains is a predication of economic and social trends for the area’s future and a tangible understanding of the significance of these statistics.
 

4 Alexander Boccon-Gibod Analyzing Historic Rights-of-Way (ROW) in metro Boston

5 Mendel Keller Socio-Economic Trends in Brooklyn Neighborhoods  
6 Hadrian Merced Evaluating Montreal's proposed Pink Line in the context of public transit accessibility The mayor of Montreal has a plan to construct a new Pink Line for the Montreal Metro before 2025. This project serves as a starting point for an external analysis of the potential usefulness of this proposed line. I will be looking at current estimated travel times to Downtown Montreal, the city's central business district, from various locations on the island, including from locations within 50 meters of every proposed Pink Line station. My first hypothesis is that an area a certain distance from downtown close to a metro station will have a shorter travel time than another area the same distance to downtown but further from a metro station. I will be using Google's Directions API to collect this data. Time permitting, other venues for analysis include verifying Projet Montréal's claim that commute times from Montréal-Nord will be cut down by 60% and looking at socioeconomic information along the proposed line to see who will benefit from this construction project

7 Avital Vainberg  Race, Class, and School Performance in Brooklyn  This project explores the inequity in the public high school system in Brooklyn, NY based on race and socioeconomic status. Growing up in Brooklyn, I saw discrepancies in education quality across the many different communities around me. Therefore, I chose to use spatial analyses to find a correlation between race, socioeconomic status, and school performance. More specifically, the project tries to answer the question: Is public high school performance lower in areas with a high percentage of racial minorities, low-income households, and low adult educational attainment? To do so, I begin by creating three thematic maps to display the demographic data for block groups in Brooklyn, NY. The maps are on the block group level, using the U.S. Census Bureau’s geographic data for Kings County from 2017. The demographic data for each block group is from the 2017 American Community Survey five-year estimates. The first map shows the number of racial minority (non-white) residents, normalized by the total block group population. The second map shows the median-household income. The third map separates the block groups into three categories of adult education attainment: high school graduate or less, some college or bachelor’s degree, master’s degree or higher. In the next stage, I create a map of public high schools using NYC’s school point locations. The map will show each school’s performance using NYS Department of Education data for 2017-2018 average regents scores (displayed using a size gradient) and graduation rates (displayed using a color gradient). To show the correlations between the school performance and demographic maps, I will create a collection of correlation matrices, graphs, and overlay maps of school districts, block groups, and schools. I hope to shine a light on the inequities across the NYC public high school system, and start a conversation about the structural racism and classism that influence school budgets and resources.
8 Jackie Lin San Francisco Demographic Data Indicate Online Popularity of Businesses I aim to find how changing demographics affect the popularity and perception of businesses in an area. Prior research has shown that a large portion of users of online opinion platforms such as Yelp, Trip Advisor, and Google Places belong to certain demographics. For example almost 48.9% of yelp reviewers have an income of 100k+. Through observing demographic data on the census tract level, potential bias effects against certain business, which manifest in a difference ratings and reviews, may emerge more strongly for some tracts rather than others. I use San Francisco a case study because it has become the go-to example of changing demographics (gentrification and trend toward high-wage workers); extrapolating hypothetically, yelp review biases will be concentrated and magnified in this small area, affording enough variation across tracts to draw some conclusions.
9 Julia Curbera Spatiotemporal patterns in home prices, housing code violations and renovation permits in Brooklyn New York City’s Department of Housing, Preservation and Development is piloting a program that requires anyone applying for renovation or demolition permits for buildings with records of tenant harassment to confirm that tenants have been harassed in the process of renovation by completing a Certificate of No Harassment (CONH). This policy responds to a trend observed by policy makers and tenant advocates, where landlords react to increasing land values by attempting to displace lower-income tenants through neglecting their properties, and later renovating these units to charge higher rents. This study tests the spatial and temporal cycle of potential tenant harassment that the CONH pilot responds to by analyzing housing code violations and renovation permits between 2010 and 2018 in two Brooklyn neighborhoods which had similar housing stock, percentage of renters, median rents and incomes in 2010, but experienced above and below borough-average increases in home prices over the 8-year period. Neighborhood-wide trends in median home prices, housing code violations, and renovation building permits over the 8-year period are plotted and analyzed to reveal temporal lags between increases in the three variables that may confirm the sequential relationship articulated by the CONH program. Results from the temporal analysis later inform an investigation of how violations and renovation permits spatially cluster throughout each neighborhood over time.
10 Ufuoma Ovienmhada  Coastal Ecosystem Dynamics along Lake Nokoue, Benin  

 


Last modified: May 12, 2019 by Rida Qadrildelgado
Back to the 11.188 Home Page.
Back to the CRON Home Page.