Annotated Bibliography
Adams, M. H.
(2000). Florida
compromises on new building code. National Underwriter, 104(15), 4.
In Florida, the state
legislation tried to enact a stricter code, much as is currently occurring in New Orleans. The insurance companies fought against these
measures because it will cost them more money to build everything up to the new
codes. In this article the two groups
reach a compromise where buildings close to the coast have to be well
protected, but buildings farther away do not have to meet the strictest
portions of the codes.
Analysis: Louisiana and mississippi struggle to find
compromise on hurricane evacuation plan.(2003). All Things Considered, ,
1.
This is a transcript of a radio show in New Orleans. It was recorded in 2003 about the evacuation
for Hurricane Lily, which fortunately did not cause any major damage to the
city. However, the evacuation was a
virtual failure because of the traffic on the interstate because Mississippi would not
authorize one-way traffic. These issues
were being sorted out at the time of publication.
Brady, M.
(2005). Congress urged to boost building codes. National Underwriter.P
& C, 109(43), 56.
Congress has recently been debating ideas of enacting a
stricter building code in Mississippi, Alabama, and Louisiana. There was a concurrent resolution passed, but
that does not carry the force of law.
There are estimates available saying that billions of dollars in damage
could have been prevented by enforcing stricter building codes in the areas hit
by Katrina. If this is the case, many
members of Congress feel that there should be something in place to protect
these citizens.
Brodie, M., Weltzien, E., Altman,
D., Blendon, R. J., & Benson, J. M. (2006).
Experiences of hurricane katrina evacuees in houston
shelters: Implications for future planning. American Journal of Public
Health, 96(8), 1402.
A group of doctors traveled to Houston in September of 2005 to talk to
refugees currently living there. They
had residents fill out a survey gathering demographics about the people as well
as other medical data. What they observed was that most of the people suffered
either mentally or physically. There are
many areas where the public health response could improve according to this study.
By EDGAR A. POEJACKSON,Miss.
(1944, Dec 17). Giant test tube for ol' man river. New York Times
(1857-Current File), pp. SM10.
This was an experiment performed to model the effects of
various methods of controlling the Mississippi River
on the possibility of massive flooding.
Decades before Katrina, scientists all ready new the dangers of trying
to control a force as great as the Mississippi River.
Campanella, T. J. (2006). Urban resilience and the recovery
of new orleans.
American Planning Association.Journal of the American
Planning Association, 72(2), 141.
This article discussed the possibilities of rebuilding New Orleans after
Katrina. Even if the city is completely
rebuilt, if the people don’t come back, the city will not ever be the
same. The author, however, expresses
hope that New Orleans
will rebound. He sites numerous examples
of the indestructibility of most modern cities.
Carlin, R. O. M. A. N. O. (2005). New orleans
and the probability blues. The Chronicle of Higher
Education, 52(5), B.13.
This author argues the viewpoint that we would be better
off ignoring the quantified probability of another major hurricane hitting New Orleans. Instead, we should place an emphasis on
building for the worst case scenario. We
can say that a major hurricane will probably not hit New Orleans, but there is always the
possibility that this could happen. As
the author says, things that have never happened before happen every day. We need to be prepared for something that may
or may not happen.
City puts
citizens first in 2006 hurricane plan.(2006). US
Fed News Service, Including US State News, , n/a.
This was a news release from New Orleans about the discussion of
evacuation plans by city officials. They
were coming up with new ideas of how to spread the information to
everybody. There are many new resources
now available to help residents successfully evacuate in case of
emergency. Some of these resources
include websites and pamphlets and posters in public locations. The key focuses are getting everybody out and
protecting their stuff from the sort of rampant pillaging seen after Katrina.
Cornejo, R. (2006). Building up to code. Best's Review,
107(4), 24.
When this article was written, there were the beginnings of
plans for building codes all ready in place.
However, these applied only to the coast and they were strictly
optional. Many people favor stricter
measures because they may cost more now, but in the future they will pay
off. That has all ready been
demonstrated by the success of other states like Florida.
Eosco, G. M., & Hooke, W. H.
(2006). Coping with hurricanes. Bulletin of the American Meteorological
Society, 87(6), 751.
The most important step
right now is not to be in a rush to rebuild New Orleans as it always has been. Also, people should not abandon the city
completely. The author believes that now
is the time to study the past and what went wrong. These mistakes need to be corrected, not
repeated. The hurricane is tragic, but
it can also be a learning experience.
This sort of forward motion is best achieved through the balance of the
public and private sector. They need to
work together because they are interdependent.
Florida will model state
regs on standard building code.(1998). ENR
(Engineering News-Record), 241(16), 22.
This article talks about the switch that Florida made the late nineties from having
different building codes throughout the state to adopting only one standard
code for the entire state. This would
make the standards uniform and more easily enforced. Officials instated this because of the damage
done by hurricanes to Florida. This is an important example for New Orleans to follow.
Gillis, C.,
& Gatehouse, J. (2005). Why they'll be back. Maclean's,
118(38), 31.
The author believes that many of the people who left the
city of New Orleans
will soon come back. The gloomy
predictions of some of the officials will prove to be resoundingly false. The history and importance of the city are
too deeply embedded in residents that they will come back to the city. The author is very optimistic.
Gumbrecht, J. (2005). New
orleans
divided into hopeful, hopeless. Knight Ridder
Tribune Business News, ,
1.
This newspaper article reflects the opinions and beliefs
of people from many different areas of New
Orleans. The
people from French Quarter and other less damaged areas are all fairly
optimistic, at this point about a month after the storm. They only really need to clean up their homes
and resume their normal life. Most of
the neighborhoods are well rebuilt. In places
like Lakeview and the Lower Ninth Ward, most people are moving out. There was one person the author talked to who
was moving to the other side of Lake
P., like in our plan. Most of these people are angry that the
government is being so slow to respond to their needs. They cannot start to rebuild their homes
until the government organizes zoning and rebuilding laws. There is a lot of frustration and hopelessness
in these communities.
Hirsch, L.
(2005). 'We had to evacuate soon'. Modern Healthcare, 35(37), 20.
This source is a first hand account of being in New Orleans through the
hurricane. He was just starting his job
as the CEO of a local hospital. He
relates his experiences as the floods increase and patients have to be
evacuated. It gives a unique perspective
rarely thought of, namely, what do you do with people who physically can’t
drive away from the city?
Khanduri, A. (2004). Hurricane charley validates new
building code. National Underwriter.P & C, 108(34),
36.
This is yet another example of the effectiveness of the
building codes put in place in Florida
after hurricane Andrew. The author
estimates that the building codes prevented a lot of potential damage to the
towns affected by Charley. There is a
convincing argument for New Orleans to follow
the successful plans of Florida.
Klotzbach, P. (2006). Atlantic Basin Seasonal Hurricane Forecasts. 10/26/06.
http://typhoon.atmos.colostate.edu/Includes/Documents/Presentations/klotzbachbermuda2006.ppt#471,1,Slide%201.
This site has some of the best statistics of
predictions. Phil Klotzbach
is a part of the team that makes predictions each year out of the University of Colorado. There are also many useful
charts looking at the way that the error in forecasting has decreased over
time. The slide show also looks at the
trends of the past two decades. The data
shows that overall the number of storms has increased in the past decade
compared to the decade before (up to 250% in some cases).
Louisiana hones
hurricane evacuation plans.(2006). All Things Considered, , 1.
This is a transcript of a news show in Louisiana.
The host spent time talking to residents of New Orleans in one of the FEMA trailer
parks. They talk about how they are now
willing to evacuate should a storm be on its way towards the city. People do not want to go through another long
ordeal waiting for rescuers. They talked
about the evacuation plans and potential problems, like traffic.
Louisiana passes post-katrina building code.(2006). RSI, Roofing, Siding,
Insulation, 83(2), 10.
Louisiana passed the International Building Code as the standard for
all new buildings as well as some major repairs. This single code will be in effect throughout
the state replace the random little town codes that were found before
Katrina. Hopefully, this new standard
will better protect the state from future hurricanes.
Materials
shortages to continue into 2006.(2005). Northwest Construction, 11(11), 57.
Because of the massive scale of rebuilding and
construction necessary in New Orleans and other
parts of the Gulf
Coast, there has been a
shortage of materials like wood panels, lumber, and concrete. Prices have skyrocketed, which will make it
even more difficult for people to afford to rebuild their house. This affects both the city buildings and
private residences. The shortage on
concrete makes things especially hard because you can’t build a house without
first pouring the foundation.
Michael Valenti (1998, August). Preventing dam flooding. Mechanical Engineering, 120(8), 26-28.
Retrieved October 6, 2006, from Research Library Core database. (Document
ID: 32701420).
Engineers
in France
designed a novel new style of floodgate for dams, which is not manually opened
and closed like now. In an effort to
eliminate man-made errors, these new gates open and closed by the natural
forces of the water. It is dependent
only on the water level. These could
have a useful application in opening or closing gates in the levees to control
flooding in other areas.
Molodzwi Dam. (2002, February). Civil
Engineering : Magazine of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering, 10(2), 11.
Retrieved October 6, 2006, from Research Library Core database. (Document
ID: 123460981).
This
article was about the dangers of spillways.
They can be a great tool, but they have to be built to handle a lot of
extreme forces. The Molodzwi
Dam’s spillway suffered a lot of damage from erosion, and the water flooded
many of the surrounding areas. This
could be a danger seen in trying to create any sort of artificial distributary.
Montgomery,
J. (2005). Facing the crisis. Modern Healthcare, 35(37), 20.
Another CEO in a separate hospital deals with attempting to
evacuate the patients from his hospital as the water floods the hospital
shutting down the back up generators, critical to many patients. There is a very long wait for helicopters to
evacuate the hospital, and other area hospitals are also vying for the few
helicopters operating at this time.
Observations
from the wobble that saved the city.(1998). New Orleans Magazine, 33(2),
11.
This is an article written back in 1998 after hurricane
Georges just barely missed the city.
Despite the hurricane not hitting the city, the government had evacuated
the people. Throughout this evacuation,
the people encountered major problems.
The author warns that this was a lucky accident, and next time, the
hurricane will actually hit the city. It
provides a warning to the citizens of New
Orleans to be prepared for the worst.
Robinson, L.
(1999). Hurricane warning. U.S.News & World
Report, 126(22), 26.
At this time, the government in Florida was fighting about whether or not to
lighten up the building codes to lower the cost of housing. Residents were really unhappy because they
felt that their safety was put at risk because the government wanted to appease
the housing industry companies.
Ryland, H. (2005). Katrina makes the case for better
building codes. National Underwriter.P & C,
109(46), 26.
Hurricane Katrina forced people to realize the risk that
they were assuming by building weaker buildings not held to any specific
standards. In New Orleans, there is a lot of debate on what
building codes if any should be promoted.
The
major deterrent is the cost necessary to implement this course of action. It still seems necessary in the wake of the
hurricane damage.
Sawyer, T., Korman, R., Post, N., Powers, M., Armistead, T., & Chastain,Debra Rubin and Bill. (2004). Deadly hurricane
trio whips up new debate; ENR (Engineering News-Record), 253(12), 10.
Even back in
2004, officials realized that the world was entering a time of larger and more
powerful storms. In Florida, the government was taking
protective measures by discussing the possibility of strengthening the building
codes. Florida sets an impressive precedent for
other states to follow in protecting against hurricanes.
Unique flood control gates. (2002, June). Civil Engineering : Magazine of the South African Institution of
Civil Engineering, 10(6), 15. Retrieved
October 6, 2006, from Research Library Core database. (Document
ID: 181079791).
There have been engineers designing flood gates in dams
that run completely based off of the water level. They require no electrical components, so
they will not fail if the area loses electricity. They are specialized, so the amount the gat
opens is dependent on the amount of water behind it. Right now, they are used to maintain a
constant water flow out of dams and a constant water level behind the dam, but
it might be possible to modify it to be used in a river.
Home