Concept Refinement Critique
Home > Assignments > Concept refinement critique

You will be sent, by email, instructions for reviewing refined design concepts by 4 different people. For each critique that you have been assigned, review the detailed concept designs. If you are unfamiliar with the concept refinement assignment you should read it before completing this review.

Before completing this review you will need to check the team's overall system assembly so you understand how the reviewee's part fits into the overall concept. Feel free to also use the system assembly review form to comment on the overall design.

For the renderings, your comments will mostly focus on rendering technique, human use, and aesthetics.

For the images from the solid model, your comments will mostly focus on aspects of function and fabrication.

At this stage there may be other types of digital models and design details, so please comment accordingly.

As usual, when you have critical comments, it is essential to provide constructive suggestions on how to improve the work. All reviews will be made available on the course website but, as a reviewer, you will remain anonymous.

Please see the submission instructions for more details.