In this critique you will provide your classmates with feedback while practicing
your ability to assess the work of others. The review will be graded
in a binary fashion. If your required reviews are completed and thoughtful
then full credit will be received. If your reviews are either incomplete
or trite then no credit will be received.
You will be sent, by email, instructions for reviewing 4 different human-use
analyses using an online form. For each critique that you have been
assigned, read the human-use analysis and write a short review considering
clarity, thoughtfulness, thoroughness, and presentation of the material.
Keep the elements outlined in the analysis description in mind. When you have critical comments, it is essential to provide constructive suggestions on how to improve the work.
All reviews will be made available on the course website but, as a reviewer,
you will remain anonymous.
Please see the submission instructions
for more details.