6.033 Spring 2020 Calendar Information
Design Project System Critiques Hands-ons Submit Site
Office Hours Piazza

Assignment

Read "The Design Philosophy of the DARPA Internet Protocols" by Dave Clark. The original paper was published in 1988; the copy of the paper that we're using was published in 2013, and includes in-line commentary from Dave Clark.

Because networking is a new topic for many of you, we've put together a short guide to the very basics of networking. It should help de-mystify some of the vocabulary in the DARPA paper. Lecture 8 will also give you a nice overview, but you need not wait for that lecture before reading this paper.

We also recommend this guide (a bit longer, but still short), which goes into more detail than ours. It's from 2002, but the concepts still apply today.

If you are confused by any part of the DARPA paper, especially terminology, those two guides should be your first resources.

A bit of background on the paper itself:

  • This paper was written in 1988, before the Internet was commercialized. (Prior to commercialization, the NSF controlled most of the Internet the primary routes that make up the Internet. In the early nineties, they sold their assets, which allowed private corporations to gain control. As a result—of this, and of a few other things—it became easier to do business on the Internet.)
  • The paper makes occasional reference to "TCP". We will learn the details of TCP in a future lecture. For now, you only need to know that TCP provides reliable transport (see the networking guide).

The paper starts by introducing the goals of the Internet's architecture (Sections 1-3). It then dives into the details of some of these goals (Sections 4-7) before discussing implementation details and concluding.

As you read, you should think about:

  • Why did the Internet architects decide to divide TCP and IP into two separate protocols?
  • How do datagrams help the Internet achieve two of its goals: to connect existing networks and to survive transient failures?
  • If you could start from scratch, how would you redesign the Internet today? Would you keep the same principles but change their order? Would you use new principles?

Question for Recitation

Before you come to this recitation, write up (on paper) a brief answer to the following (really—we don't need more than a couple sentences for each question). If your TA has requested that you email your answer to them, you may do that instead, but it should still be handed in before your recitation begins.

Your answers to these questions should be in your own words, not direct quotations from the paper.

  • What were three of the most important goals of the early Internet?
  • How was it designed to meet those goals?
  • Why were those goals important (or, why does the author believe that those goals were important)?
As always, there are multiple correct answers for each of these questions. [an error occurred while processing this directive]