MIT AATT Model Project

RAMS: Reorganized ATC Mathematical Simulator

(Last update: 02/96 EMF)

1. Model Category

General purpose ATC modelling environment for enroute/terminal airspace and controller workloads.

2. Summary

RAMS is a fast-time simulation tool developed by the Eurocontrol Experimental Center (EEC) at Bretigny (France) and CACI Inc.. RAMS is a major upgrade of EAM (Eurocontrol Airspace Model) which for the past 15 years has been Eurocontrol's principal simulation tool for evaluating proposed changes to airspace structure and sector configuration in EC member states. RAMS deals with all segments of flights starting from take-off till just before landing. However, runway interactions with airborne operations may be modelled, such as for parallel or intersecting runways.

RAMS provides a flexible airspace simulation environment where a broad variety of new concepts may be tested at the desired level of detail. Due to the flexible design of RAMS, the system is capable of carrying out planning, organizational, high-level, or in-depth studies of a wide range of ATC concepts. This design includes 4-dimensional flight profiles, conflict detection and conflict resolution mechanisms, workload models, modern user interfaces and a data preparation environment.

RAMS offers an integrated simulation study environment, with many advanced features to assist the user in the development, simulation and analysis of an ATC system.

Models that may compete with RAMS include TAAM, ASIM, and, to a lesser degree, SIMMOD.

3. Input Requirements

Airspace description: The format used for sector definition is based on a list of corner points, 2D boundaries (a list of connected points), and the airspace definition (to add the third dimension and ATC information). RAMS has an integrated database facility which allows the exraction of data from a number of sources including the Jeppesen database of Europe, Eurocontrol or CFMU. If it is required to parse another, unsupported format, RAMS offers the possibility for users to define BNF style parsing facilities without a requirement to modify the RAMS code. FAA users have reported temporary difficulties because of the unusual airspace definition format leading sometimes to overlapping sectors when corner points are redundant.

Rule-based resolution system: RAMS may work with or without automatic conflict resolution. It may also run in real- time, and a human controller can then interact with the software. When running in automatic mode, each controller in RAMS may be attributed a specific set of rules (the basic ATC conflict resolution rulebase contains over 100 rules) that RAMS will use for automatic conflict resolution. These rules may be defined sectorwise to account for local habits and working conditions.
Conflict probes can use a variety of conflict alert zone shapes. The basic shapes are rectangles, circles, ellipsoids, diamonds and users are required to select one of these only.
The separation values applied to aircraft are defined by any one of a number of sources, including the required controller separation, wake turbulence, oceanic flight metering fixes and the relative geometry of the flights in a conflict. All these features are optional and may be modified by the user.

Flight plan description: RAMS offers the capability of simulating the entire flight plan in as much detail as desired. It can also generate flight plans automatically: Given a cruising altitude, the origin and the destination of a flight, RAMS can generate a flight plan with a climb path and a descent path based on specific aircraft performance. Aircraft performance is currently coded on lookup tables.

Workload analysis: A virtually unlimited number of tasks may be defined for workload analysis purposes.

Weather patterns - Special use airspace: Convective weather patterns and Special Use Airspace can be accounted for via time- varying forbidden zones.

4. Outputs

By carrying out comparative analyses between different simulated scenarios, the effects of proposed changes can be expressed in terms of:

• Distribution of workload over centers, sectors, and individual control positions;
• Traffic loads within each sector/center overall and per route, level band, point, classified according to cruise, climb and descent;
• Penalties imposed upon traffic resulting from imposing ATFM measures, flight level changes, en-route/ground delays, and arrival holding.
• Frequency distribution based on many iterations of a given scenario (Monte-Carlo simulations).

Users of RAMS have mentioned however that RAMS post-processing capabilities are rather poor. The feeling is that the output is mainly made of large, unprocessed output files (trajectories, conflict start and end times).

CSSI seems to have developed a graphical tool based on SDAT, an interactive airspace building tool, to post-process some of RAMS' outputs. The contact name at CSSI is Stephane Mondoloni.

5. Major Assumptions

Unknown.

6. Computational Characteristics

Hardware Requirements: The system runs on a HP9000 series 700 workstations. There are currently no plans to implement RAMS on any other machine.

Software Requirements: RAMS comprises over 160,000 lines of ModsimII. Machines with 256 Mb of RAM or higher and a disk of 4 Gb or more are recommended for serious use of the system. MODSIM II is a fully object oriented simulation language developed by CACI Products Company that generates C code. It runs under UNIX under X-windows or its HP-Vue Window equivalent. The source code is not available to any users.

Execution Characteristics: Typical speeds can range from 3 to 20 times real-time, depending on the desired simulation. Very small simulations may run up to 100 times real-time. FAA users have reported that it took 10 hours to run a 1-day, 12,000 flight simulation without conflict resolution.

Documentation: According to the FAA users, the documentation to users is "adequate", and the graphical user interface is "adequate to good". A future site for RAMS information, documentation, online user support, users group and News/Discussion forum will be defined soon.

7. Learning Efforts

RAMS is reportedly a relatively easy model to use and to get started with. According to the developers, two weeks are necessary to get familiar with RAMS. FAA users reported 1 month as necessary to really get comfortable. A typical initial study may require frequent phone calls to Eurocontrol.

8. Modularity and Flexibility

RAMS is currently a closed-architecture software. However, the next step in the development of RAMS includes moving towards an open-loop architecture, where externally developed modules could bypass some of RAMS' functions (conflict resolution, for example).

9. Status

RAMS official release 2.0 was carried out in November 1995. RAMS 2.1 is released internally to Eurocontrol and will be available early May 1996.

Current RAMS users include Eurocontrol Experimental Center, FAA/OR Washington, AENA Madrid, Transport Canada. Demands for RAMS have been received from CENA (France), Irish CAA, NATS (UK), DFS Frankfurt and MIT. A first RAMS user's group meeting is planned for June 1996.

10. Extent of Model Verification

RAMS has been tested by FAA in a study to evaluate the effects of direct routing on airspace operations in New England. It has been reported as "the best available airspace simulation tool".

11. Principal Applications

• ATC workload
• Free Routing investigation
• Free Flight investigations
• Airspace capacity, density

12. Availability

RAMS is available from Eurocontrol. Currently, RAMS availability needs to be negociated on a case-by-case basis.

13. Contacts

Contacts in Europe:

Frank Jelinek
RAMS External Client Support
Model Development Team (MDV)
BP 15
91222 Bretigny sur Orge cedex
France
Tel: (1) 69 88 73 93
Fax: (1) 60 85 15.04\
Email: frank.jelinek@eurocontrol.fr

RAMS support team
Email: ramssupport@eurocontrol.fr
Web: http://www.eurocontrol.fr/~mdv

Contacts in the United States:

Mr. Steve Bradford
FAA
(202) 358 5234
sbradford@mail.hq.faa.gov

Mr. Stephane Mondoloni
CSSI
(202) 488-0003
Stephane.Mondoloni@mail.hq.faa.gov

14. Report sources

This report is based on an interview conducted on January 11, 1996, at Eurocontrol with Ian Crook and an interview conducted on December 18, 1995, with Steve Bradford (FAA), Stephane Mondoloni, Willie Weiss and Bill Colligan, all of CSSI.

15. Summary Evaluation

RAMS is a new airspace simulation tool developed for Eurocontrol. This tool concentrates on airspace operations. While currently being a closed-architecture tool, RAMS apparently offers enough degrees of freedom to investigate many aspects of future concepts such as flying direct routes. However, this simulation tool is very recent and extensive usage is necessary to fully assess its capabilities.


Back to completed models page