"What fell, possibly not existent, thing do we think this is?" - TommyDetermining where Emil Schergen's old house was is deemed to be important, but it's Sunday and most of the places one would look to determine this will be closed.
Esme, back in Boston, reads about yet another vanishment. She calls Peter's house, with Junior crying fretfully in the background. Junior misses Mommy, apparently. Esme also calls the Globe to ask about the article, but is told that the reporter on the scene is, in fact, on the scene in Greenfield / North Ashfield, and unavailable to talk to her, and she is unable to get an address for the Carter farm (site of the third disappearance).
However, Tommy, who has gone to report about the search at the sheriff's headquarters (he is subject to some mocking about having taken an eleven-year-old kid on the trip), is able to peek at the map and see where the farm is. Tomy, Roderick, and Charlie go off to Sunday service; the Apcotts are there, and Mattie invites them to dinner. (Mrs. Apcott is not entirely pleased by Mattie taking this upon herself, but does reissue the invitation on her own).
Esme arrives, along with Junior, and Cherie, a French parlormaid ostensibly along to look after Junior. Charlie examines Junior closely for any possible resemblance to Dr. Schreber - one possible point of similarity is that Junior's hair is blonder than either Gerti's or Charlie's (though still a bit darker than Dr. Schreber's). Esme is filled in on the plot - she's not at all convinced that after ripping three people to shreds and vanishing three other people, the monster would go back and hide in the well again.
"Our obession seems to have hinged upon the well, so perhaps we should deal with that before it gets worse." - RoderickTommy lowers the lantern on a rope, but it swings back and forth too wildly and smashes against the side of the well. Charlie does a better job with the next lantern, but it's very deep, so while they can make out some ?stones? and ?branches? and ?headstones? there's not much detail. No monsters, though, and nobody feels compelled to climb down the eighty feet.
Roderick heads to the church to look at Reverend Witherspoon's diary, and comes up with some more details about Emil's death and burial.
Next, it is deemed time to talk to the families of some of the missing people, and Esme, Charlie, and Tommy head out. Unfortunately, the Carter house appears to be beseiged by reporters, so the group doesn't add to the pestering. The Donovan house looks more peaceful. Hugh Donovan is polite, but provides no information of use. Myra is presumed to have vanished while out for a walk, though she didn't say goodbye before leaving. While this was less common for her, her parents were for the most part in less accessible rooms that evening, so she might not have bothered. Alternately, perhaps she vanished from inside the house.
As the group is leaving, though, Susie (the Donovan's youngest daughter, age six), intercepts Esme outside to tell her about having seen Myra last night - she came to the window and knocked to get in, but Susie thought Myra was playing a joke, since the window was on the second floor, and didn't let her in. Esme advises Susie to tell her sister to come downstairs and use the front door next time, and to tell her parents. Meanwhile, Charlie and Tommy, looking around outside,
The group returns to tell Roderick about this. He shows them the copy of the diary entry he's made. Roderick also makes a big twiggy cross out of hawthorn branches, and puts it under his shirt. Esme is very concerned about how to protect the Donovans from Myra's return the next evening. Roderick, recalling various things about vampires, starts tying knots in a long piece of clothesline, so that in case the vampires are Hungarian, they'd have to stop and untie the knots before doing anything else.
There's some discussion as to whether all this is related to Ezekial or not. Roderick doubts it. Esme doubts Roderick's doubts.
"What, this is just the world's unluckiest town?" - EsmeShould they stay at the Donovan house to watch for Myra? How will they convince the Donovans of this? And what will they tell the Donovans if their daughter does show up and they stake her? Maybe they should hide outside? Right, says Roderick, let's all stand in the middle of a dark field and wait for vampires.
Charlie notes that Cheri and Junior and Mel Razen are all outside on the lawn. He goes and retrieves Junior, glaring at Mel.
Tommy tells the Apcotts that he regrets they can't come to dinner after all. The question of what to tell the Donovans is still open, though. Roderick and Dr. Schreber go to talk to Reverend Connolly about vampires. He thinks they're deeply troubled, and suggests that perhaps Reverend Witherspoon's belief in vampires is not proof but allows them to borrow some crosses (perhaps on the theory that crosses never hurt).
"As a dry run for convincing the Donovans, that was truly awful. -RoderickBut what if she does show up? What do they do? Brandish crosses? Get hit with a shovel by the irate father?
"I suppose we could all just lurk in the car with the doors locked. -Roderick
"We could all watch them die from a distance..." -Tommy
"Could we lie to them to get into the house?" -Dr. Schreber
"The best case is that she eloped in the confusion, came back to talk to her sister, and brought a ladder." -RoderickCharlie notes that Cherie is listening to all this in the kitchen. He goes to talk to her. She asks if he really believes it is "ze nosferatu" and makes little finger-fang motions, and bats her eyes at him. Charlie smiles glassily and sits down to talk to her. From the other room, Dr. Schreber is furious, and calls out to her to leave Charlie be, girl, there are important things to discuss! Cherie is hurt, and bats her eyes, asking if Charlie is going to let him say such things to her. Charlie tells Dr. Schreber to leave Cheri alone. Dr. Schreber says he's going upstairs to check on Gerti. Charlie, coming briefly to his senses, chases upstairs after him. Gerti is still asleep.
A truce is reached, and the party heads for the Donovans'. They manage to convince Hugh that they should be allowed to stay overnight, without entirely specifying why, but nothing happens other than the occasional creepy noise.