Volume 15, Number 3

Home
Bangkok subway
IAP in Hawaii
Bridge contest
Students in Germany
Groundwater cleanup
Ladd symposium
Reader's notes
Graduating's really fine!
New environmental lab
Comings & goings

Theoretical modeling on land, sand, harbors, and sea.

 

Venice's fabled intimacy with the sea has become a little too close, a little too often, with over 50 floods a year in recent times. Photo credit: Consorzio Venezia Nuova

As acting head for the CEE Dept., Prof. CC Mei is spending the year juggling the new administrative duties with his heavy research load and teaching schedule. Some of his many areas of interest are summarized below.

Venice is sinking

Without some kind of drastic intervention, the city of Venice with its glorious architecture will suffer more frequent flooding as sea level rises steadily. (Currently it floods about 50 times a year, compared to around six times a year a century ago.) Among the more practical schemes to prevent this irreplaceable loss to the Western cultural heritage is a set of flood gates designed to span the three inlets of Venice Lagoon. These gates are hollow boxes hinged on a common axis fixed on the seabed, but are otherwise unconnected to each other. As they allowed to swing to and fro about the axis, only a small part of the wave force is borne by the supporting structure. In normal weather they would remain discretely hidden on the seabed. During stormy seas, the flood gates would swing up and act as a dam to prevent the storm tide from swamping the low-lying city.

Several MIT faculty members have been advisors to Venice on the environmental impacts of the mobile gates project, including Profs. Rafael Bras and Donald Harleman of CEE, Chryssostomos Chryssostomidis of Ocean Engineering, and Paola Rizzoli of Earth and Planetary Sciences. Prof. CC Mei, the new acting head of the CEE Dept., has been advising the Consorzio Venezia Nuova on one of the troublesome aspects of gate design.

While the gates were originally intended to swing in unison, the neighboring gates were found in later experiments to swing in opposite directions, thus creating large openings and reducing their effectiveness as a dam. Mei and former Parson Lab students Paolo Sammarco '97 (PhD), Hoang Tran '96 (SM), and Roxy Liao '99 (SM) have performed theoretical and experimental research to understand and predict the strange oscillations, to make proper adjustments in design.

In addition to the engineering problems, debates on the suitability of the mobile gates have enlivened Italian politics. "Concerns about design effectiveness and environmental impact have been hot topics of controversy," says Mei. "Some people have recommended alternative measures such as building little breakwaters around the city's islands, rather than installing big visible steel structures. Frequent changes in the political climate have also impeded the progress of the project." As of press time, the current Italian government approves of the gates.

Venice is no longer sinking now that the industries in the surrounding area have stopped pumping out large amounts of groundwater. However, the frequency and intensity of flooding continue to increase due to global climate change and a slow rise in sea level. Side affects of regular floods include widespread corrosion, decaying buildings and structure, and a steady stream of disgruntled people moving out of the city. Conversely, Mei notes that some tourists arrive precisely to see floods.

Ancient buildings in Venice might look charming, but the less delightful antique sewage system overflows and sullies the canal water which overflows onto the streets and into houses. As always, people adjust to new inconveniences. "All the homeowners put down wooden planks to protect their floors when they know a flood is coming. All electrical outlets must be located 1 m above the floor. The local people know to wear boots, but the tourists usually aren't prepared. As water rises in the canals, some of the water taxis can't fit under low bridges and traffic comes to a stop. The flood gate is a very good, effective way to reduce this sort of damage, and to give the city more time to find a long term solution," says Mei.

While Mei attributes the origins of breakwater engineering to the Egyptians about 4000 years ago, "The Venice breakwater design is quite novel and technologically very advanced. People have to think about environmental impacts of any big civil engineering projects now. It's a very interesting project for us both from the engineering and the environmental point of view. Also, this project involves intense politics, and dealing with people is a special feature of civil engineering."

Sandbars

Another of Mei's projects looks at the formation of various kinds of sandy features on the sea bed due to wave and current motions, such as sandbars and sand ripples. Basic questions include how are they formed, how do they affect the shore climate, and do they have any effects on waves, currents, etc.

 

Sandbars look like a line of heavy waves moving toward shore on Chesapeake Bay. Photo supplied by C.C. Mei

"It turns out to be a chicken-and-egg problem," says Mei. Waves and currents affect the presence of sandbars and ripples, which in turn affect waves and currents. "This very interesting natural problem has engineering implications. Mining sand to make cement and concrete often takes place at sandbars. It's of great interest to engineering and coastal geology to know where the sandbars are and how they evolve after storms."

From studying the effect of sandbars, Mei points out that under certain conditions, sandbars seem to protect the shore. There have been suggestions that sandbars should be specifically built as breakwaters. However, "in a recent thesis, Jie Yu '00 (PhD) showed theoretically that this suggestion is not reliable. How much energy the sandbars reflect depends very much on where they are located in reference to the waves, but the waves constantly change timing and direction. Sandbars can move with the waves, as well. A stationary sandbar cannot protect against perpetually changing waves."

Transport of contaminants

In shallow water such as inland lakes, contaminants often bind to very fine, muddy particles in the sediments. Predicting the movement of the sediments is very important for knowing how the contaminants are transported. These fine particles originally sink to the bottom, but they can be stirred up by waves, currents, dredging, and other disturbances.

"Since waves are created by the action of wind, it is important to study the effect of wind on water and how waves are generated. In turn, we want to know how waves churn up the sea bottom and mobilize the fine particles. Once they're mobilized into suspension, how do these fine particles move about in the water body? Do they stay mostly on the bottom, or do they float everywhere?" asks Mei, who is doing some fundamental studies on this subject with grad student Zhenghua Huang.

When the wind blows on the surface of lakes or rivers, very regular streaks of leaves or debris form on the water surface, called Langmuir circulation. (Irving Langmuir [1881-1957] realized that the formation of streaks indicated some sort of vortices which tend to cause flow to converge along certain lines in one direction, and then diverge below the sea surface.)

"We are trying to understand this phenomenon more theoretically, particularly in shallow water," specifies Mei. "In addition to this mechanism on the surface which Langmuir observed, how would the circulation affect the bottom? In what way would the circulation also mobilize very fine particles and transport particles across the water? This is a fundamental fluid dynamic question with the ultimate aim of understanding how fine particles are transported in very shallow water, inland lakes, and possibly rivers. The problem is of interest to engineers, environmentalists, and oceanographers."

Harbor engineering

Many harbors such as Long Beach, CA, and inland harbors on the Great Lakes are plagued by very long period wave oscillations. Harbors have always been designed to protect ships from waves due to wind coming from outside, often with breakwaters to deflect waves back to the sea. "Even though sea waves have short periods of about 10 seconds, very often you can observe long period oscillations of about 100 seconds inside the harbor," notes Mei. "The mooring lines which keep the ships in a fixed position also have a natural frequency very close to that 100 seconds." If the ships oscillate at these long periods, it puts a severe strain on the mooring system and can snap these thick cables.

Mei was on the technical review committee for Long Beach harbor about five years ago, where Pier J, which was rented to the Danish container company Mersk, was big enough to dock six container ships. "The company complained that their ships had experienced long period oscillations, and rocked so strongly that it slowed down the loading and unloading operations. Extra time costs extra money. In addition, sometimes as many as one big steel mooring cable per day would snap, causing workers in these loading operations to drop down or fall off the boats." Mersk asked the harbor to fix this problem, or else both it and Long Beach would lose money if it was forced to find another harbor and use a different shipping route.

"One of the engineering and technical challenges is to know why long period oscillations exist in the harbor where all the sea waves coming in from great distances are short period. This is not easy to understand," says Mei.

Mengyi Chen from Taiwan is developing a nonlinear theory with Mei about how to predict long-term oscillations in the harbor even though the incoming wind waves are short. When Mei was on the Long Beach committee, "there was no good way to predict how long waves can be generated by short waves. Therefore the port authority asked the Corps of Engineers' Coastal Engineers Research Center to do laboratory simulations. They built a harbor in the big wave basin in Vicksburg, and send in very long waves to excite oscillations of equal period in harbors. This is a linear mechanism. But waves coming from the Pacific Ocean are known to have little energy in these long periods. However, that's the usual way that many researchers run this type of test."

New breakwaters costing $25 million have been built to protect Pier J based on this type of study. Whether they are effective may take years to find out. Mei speculates, "It may work, or it may work for the wrong reason, or it may not work all the time. But nobody knows. I was never satisfied with that kind of situation. We think that when we complete our theoretical model of how long period waves in harbors are generated by short waves, it will have far reaching applications for many harbors in the world."

Rearranging fluid mechanics

CEE is involved in the I-Campus project to streamline the first year graduate course on fluid mechanics. "Fluid mechanics is a basic subject for almost every kind of engineering discipline- mechanical, nuclear, civil, ocean, aeronautical- and in quite a few science departments, such as Earth and Planetary Science," states Mei. "Over the years, almost every department has established a course on graduate fluid mechanics. Not only is there duplication, but because each department teaches its own fluid mechanics course, it reduces the intellectual interaction between departments. Most of us think this is not desirable."

As a result, professors from five departments-CEE (Heidi Nepf), Mechanical Engineering (Ain Sonin and Triantapyllos Akylas), Ocean Engineering (Dick Yue), Aero/Astro (Marck Drela), and Mathematics (John Bush) are collaborating on a revised course. "With support from the Provost of the School of Engineering and the Microsoft iCampus project, we want to see how information technology can help us design a modular course so that students from across the Institute can take some modules dealing with common and basic principles, and other modules showing various applications of fluid mechanics," says Mei.

"The aim is to reduce redundancy in teaching and create more exciting interactions between different departments, resulting in more effective teaching for all students. The increasing use of the Internet will make visualizations, numerical simulations, etc., more effective and interesting to the students. We hope to change the way that fluid mechanics is taught at MIT. E hope to start an experiment which will not only affect the teaching of fluid mechanics, but may have implications on the teaching of similar basic topics such as solid mechanics, thermodynamics, and control theory."

Even as he hopes that CEE rapidly finds "an outstanding head very soon to relieve me," Mei promises "to do my best to keep things going. I've been here ever since graduating from Cal Tech. I've enjoyed many exciting years in this department, and it's a chance to pay it back through administrative service."
 

Out of sight most of the time, the Venice gates would stretch across the vulnerable lagoon openings during rough weather to block out storm surges. Photo credit: Consorzio Venezia Nuova

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

"Civil and Environmental Engineering at MIT"
is published quarterly by the
Civil and Environmental Engineering Department at Massachusetts Institute of Technology,
Bldg. 1-383, 77 Mass. Ave., Cambridge, MA 02139

Editor: Debbie Levey
(617)253-7101
levey@mit.edu