





"Civil and Environmental Engineering at
MIT"
is published quarterly by the
Civil and Environmental Engineering Department at Massachusetts Institute of
Technology,
Bldg. 1-383, 77 Mass. Ave., Cambridge, MA 02139
Editor: Debbie Levey
(617)253-7101
levey@mit.edu
| |
Terrascope group tackles tough issues, treks to Amazon
 |
| Michael Fettiplace '06 and
colleagues explored the Amazon rain forest starting from the
research station at the Impa Tropical Forest Fragmentation Research
Center, Brazil. (Photo: Helen McCreery) |
Fired by youthful enthusiasm, every year freshmen in the MIT
Terrascope program tackle some of the planet's most vexing and complex problems.
This self-selected group of around 40 new students "doesn't necessarily
share much in common aside from a lively interest in the general topic of earth
systems," explains CEE Prof. Rafael Bras, who teaches one of their two core
courses. Last year the program focused on the Amazon rainforest, complete with a
thrilling week for students and staff to roam around the Brazilian jungle.
Terrascope is part of the Earth Systems initiative, which is largely a
collaboration between CEE and Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences. The
co-directors are Profs. Sallie Chisholm from CEE, and Kip Hodges from EAPS.
Students congregate in their own room in Bldg. 16 and must take two required
Terrascope courses in their freshman year: 12.000 Mission 200X, (now up
to Mission 2007), taught in fall by Hodges, and 1.016 Earth Systems
Engineering and Science, led by Bras and Ari Epstein in spring. An optional
course by Epstein and Bras in IAP (January intersession) feeds into the spring
class.
Mission 2000X and Earth Systems Engineering tackle a difficult, adventurous
theme which changes every year. Previous years have considered strategies to
explore Mars for signs of life, and to design permanent research stations in the
ocean. For 2002-03, the theme was how to characterize and monitor the well-being
of the Amazon Basin rainforest, and devise a set of practical strategies for
sustainable development.
Given this "very broad, very open question with many parts, students are
provided with material and resources from experts and from dedicated
librarians," says Bras. "At the end of the fall term, the students had
to form a single team with subgroups, and create a web system that explains
their strategy for the Amazon sustainability, and a real time webcast with a
panel of experts that questioned them in front of a live audience. It is a very
open-ended activity with no single 'right' answers."
Having read about Terrascope over the summer before freshman orientation, Helen
McCreery '06 already knew that she was "really interested in the
environment, but I didn't know what I wanted to do." During the first
semester "we designed strategies to save the rainforest. Looking back, I
think we could have done it in much better ways, but that was the pointwe had
to learn to work in groups." As part of the fauna team, McCreery
concentrated on techniques to monitor populations of animals, and the effects of
humans on the animals. "We decided that the bat was a good way to monitor.
If the bat population is healthy, the other populations are usually healthy, and
bats are easy to monitor."
|
| Helen McCreery found her
ecological niche in the Amazon. |
Museum exhibits
Bras's class, Earth Systems Engineering and Science, was offered for the first
time in the spring '03 term. It was intended to create more depth on the yearly
topic with a hands-on engineering team experience, in which the students
conceptualized, made a preliminary design and final design, then built the
project.
After much brainstorming, the students divided into teams to choose a particular
theme to illustrate something they had learned in the first term about the
Amazon. Topics included comparing Boston and Manaus, and what lives in the
different levels of the forest canopy. They then developed an appropriate museum
exhibit aimed at an audience on the level of a junior or senior in high school.
To get some idea about what constitutes a good museum exhibit, the class met
with designers from the New England Aquarium, the Boston Museum of Science, the
Worcester Ecotarium, the Franklin Park Zoo and the Children's Museum. The
students critiqued the museum exhibits, and sat down with the designers to ask
questions. "They learned about the process and about the subject matter.
There were some lectures, but largely they did the research on their own,"
says Bras.
Of the various criteria for the exhibit, the most important was that it had to
be the right level for the target high school viewer. Knowledge had to be
presented at different levels of difficulty, and each exhibit needed an
interactive element. The students' prototype of the interactive component was
tested in the Museum of Science with a real audience, allowing the students to
see how people actually reacted and whether the prototypes conveyed the desired
idea. "It was fascinating. At the end of the term the groups had built
seven extraordinary exhibits, some very ambitious," says Bras.
To show how researchers might examine a section of Amazon forest, one group
constructed a science station from wooden beams, adding realism with a hammock
and instruments for specific tasks. "Within that context, they explained
some science issues that they were interested in. When you stood inside, it felt
as if research was really going on. For the interactive part, students provided
soil samples to test for salinity. Depending on where you stuck a measurement
probe into the soil, a gauge would show whether the soil was salinized or not.
The answer led to a picture which predicted the health of the ecosystems within
that level of salinity." The most attractive interactive element in the
science station turned out to be the hammock. "Whether you were a kid or an
adult, you could lie on the hammock under the mosquito net," notes Bras.
After students completed their exhibits, they were judged by faculty and by
museum experts from all over the region, largely through connections of co
teacher Ari Epstein. In his multidisciplinary career, he has assembled and led a
number of exhibit-development teams at the New England Aquarium which involved
scientists, designers, educators and others.
The projects were displayed either in the open areas of Parsons Lab, or in the
Terrascope Room in Bldg. 16. "They transformed the room. As you walked in,
you entered the Amazon at Night, where it was completely dark," describes
Bras. "The web of life was their interactive display. By pressing buttons,
you could eliminate a layer of animals such as snakes, trees, or large cats, and
see how it affects the other layers. The lights go off for the group which has
been annihilated, and ultimately when you eliminate the whole forest, the whole
display goes dark."
Two full-sized huts housed the Indigenous People exhibit. Inside, visitors could
explore several interactive activities, including a computer with an Indian
legend narrated by one of the students, questions on the computer, and a place
to sit on the floor and experience a religious ritual of initiation.
"I had more fun in that class designing museum exhibits, mostly because I
like working with my hands," recalls McCreery. "Also, it didn't seem
like such a daunting task because we were only responsible for our own small
group. I didn't really know anything about how museum exhibits go up, so I
learned. "My group compared Boston with Manaus, a major city in the
rainforest with almost two million people. It was really fun working on how we
could present concepts such as food, music, language, and odors. There was a lot
of problem solving and a lot of effort, but it was ultimately rewarding."
Interactive activities for the city comparison included a game to match simple
phrases in English with the translation in Brazilian Portuguese. If the correct
phrases were touched, a light would shine. Another popular activity was based on
scents. "Every morning here, most people drink orange juice. But in Manaus
they have passionfruit juice and other juices that I couldn't even identify. We
had orange smell and passionfruit smell for people to try to guess, and then
they could open a cupboard see a picture to find out if they were right. Some
people got the orange right away, but nobody recognized the passionfruit.
"Boston and Manaus are completely different in some ways, and in some ways
they're really similar," assesses McCreery. "Manaus felt like a city;
it's crowded with massive marketplaces, and there is a lot of poverty. Like
Boston, the city contains many nationalities. The climate obviously is different
and affected many phases of life. As is the case with any two cities, people
behave differently. All public schools there have uniforms. There's one
university, as opposed to the crazy number around Boston. The food was amazing:
fried bananas, chicken dishes, and many fruits which we don't have up
here."
 |
| Projects needed continual
modifications and group problem solving. These students built a
model tropical research station complete with hammock, mosquito
nets, and experimental equipment. (Photo: Ari Epstein) |
The Amazon trip itself
As part of the Terrascope experience, and especially for getting some personal
experience for designing the museum exhibit, the whole class traveled to the
Amazon during spring vacation in March. The party consisted of 40 freshmen, 5
upperclass tutors, a graduate student, Profs. Kip Hodges, Ari Epstein, Bras, and
Bras' wife Patricia. Students had already made a preliminary design of their
interactive museum display, but after they returned, "they changed
everything completely in the week before the project was due," says Bras.
Getting to the Amazon required more than 24 hours of travel, recounts McCreery,
"but it was worth it. We drove to New York, flew south to Saġ Paolo, flew
north to Manaus, the capital of the Brazilian state of Amazonas, and rode a boat
about three hours upstream on the Rio Negro to the hotel. When we got off the
boat at the hotel, we were exhausted. Immediately a brilliantly colorful parrot
flew three feet over my head and almost hit me. It was so amazing, it made me
realize, 'Wow, I'm here!' That made me really excited and happy."
Perched on stilts in the forest canopy, the various parts of the hotel were
connected by long covered walkways. "At night it's fascinating. In the
forest it's surprising how few animals you see, because they hide and the trees
are high. It's not easy to find birds in the canopy. But in the hotel we saw
lots of wildlife from the walkways. Some of the monkeys were friendly and some
weren't. At other times we saw caimans, alligators, birds, macaws. In the middle
of the night when it's pitch dark, you go on the walkways and the sounds are
mind boggling," recalls Bras.
While half of the group explored from the hotel, the other half settled at the
Impa Tropical Forest Fragmentation Research Center in the jungle for three days
and two nights. "That experience was great. There was just a tin shed and
hammocks side by side, close enough so that if you turn over at night, you hit
the person next to you," says Bras. "It was truly an unforgettable
experience for everyone. I've studied the Amazon for 15 years, and it changes
your perspective as you go to different parts. There are vines all over the
forest. We saw monkeys and at night we heard the howler monkeys roar like lions.
We saw evidence of jaguar having been nearby, but we never saw one."
With the combination of industrial-strength insect repellant, mosquito net
around their cots, and an unusually dry stretch at the beginning of the wet
season, the group found the insect population under control. Earlier in the
semester students had listened to precautions in the rain forest "to make
sure they didn't do something stupid," says Bras. "They were very
good, although there were a few incidents where people were careless. Somebody
fell asleep in a hammock without insect repellant, and when he woke up, he was
completely swollen. However, because of the drought, there were fewer mosquitoes
than in my yard in Lexington, MA."
For McCreery, the highlight of the trip was unquestionably the research center.
"It was another long trip, driving for hours in jeeps along dirt roads. It
was really secluded. Since we slept in hammocks outside with mosquito netting,
and there were only shelters with no walls, we were completely exposed to the
whole rainforest. Just hearing the sounds at night was exciting. The camp was
set up like a grid with stakes along the paths that gave the coordinates, making
it hard to get lost. We took many hikes in big groups, but we could also go off
in smaller groups," with the advantage of being quieter and stopping more
frequently to poke around. "A large group is fine for some things, but you
can't really keep it quiet and observe everything."
Despite leaving at 5 AM every day for excursions, McCreery never felt tired
"because it was so exhilarating. Coming back to the hotel after the
research camp was anticlimactic. When we had first arrived, the hotel had been
amazing, but it seemed sort of touristy after the research camp." She
responded similarly to Manaus, which offered the usual attractions of a large
foreign city, along with visits to an Indian native village, and a tribal
village. "It's interesting to see their way of life. But being in the
Amazon really made me decide to do environmental engineering. At the research
camp, I just didn't want to ever leave."
Among the new and amazing sights for McCreery were brilliant blue, shiny
butterflies which glinted in the sunlight and were visible from improbably long
distances. At night, phosphorescent fungi glowed along the paths and illuminated
their way in the intense tropical darkness. "One night we went out and
caught bats in a huge wall of nets. We found a massive cockroach which was three
or four inches long. While the big animals stayed hidden, we saw a toucan and
some monkeys high up in the trees, and poisonous spiders." To her surprise,
the rainforest turned out to be shades of green rather than filled with riotous
color (aside from blue butterflies). "I was expecting the plants to be
really colorful, but mostly it was just a very thick mass of green. One of the
only plants that was something other than shades of green had dark red flowers
with long, triangular petals on a vertical plane, and tiny white buds in the
middle.
"From far away and just for a split second, we saw pink dolphins in the
Amazon. For some reason I was convinced that piranha were tiny, but we fished
for them and I found that they're about 6 inches (15 cm). One of the employees
from the hotel dove in the river and caught a baby caiman, about 3 ft (0.9 m)
long. We all got to hold it and feel how smooth its skin is, like snakeskin. At
a fish museum we saw 10-ft (3 m) long fish swimming around in a massive
aquarium. There were just so many things I had never imagined before, and so
many species which don't exist up here.
"The trees were so tall that the roots have a buttress system for support.
The base of the trunk separates into projections like branches which grow into
the soil. Some trees didn't even have a solid trunk, just many little
projections spreading out and digging into the soil. At one clearing we could
see the wall of trees, and when most of the group was on the other side of the
watering hole, we could barely spot the people because the trees were so tall.
It looked like a mountain with trees on it, but it was solid trees. It was dark
because the trees shut out most of the light."
 |
| Not everything in CEE is
done at the touch of a computer button: Catherine Yao and Joey Miler
work on a model of how the tawny Solimoes River and dark Rio Negro
meet to form the Amazon. The two very distinct bodies of water run
side by side for about 10 km before mixing. (Photo: Ari Epstein) |
One of the more striking sights was the confluence of the Rio Negro and what
becomes the Amazon when the tributaries join. The two broad rivers begin as
completely different colored waters, "one very dark like good tea, and the
other filled with yellow sediment, and they retain their characteristic color
for about 10 km (6.2 miles), flowing side by side without really mixing,"
says Bras. "Gazing across the dark Rio Negro from a distance, the yellow
tributary looks just like a sand beach rather than another river. We were all
just staring at it. It was so counter-intuitive that it was ridiculous!"
recalls McCreery. Students were so impressed that they devoted one of their
group museum exhibits to this phenomenon.
Over the year, the students bond through group work, small Terrascope classes,
and hanging out in the attractive common room with its kitchen and computer
cluster. While some upperclass activities are being planned, such as a Scholars
program and a UROP (undergraduate research project), students have also taken
their own initiatives. Two students carried out a UROP on the concept of
forest-friendly beef, to be marketed at a premium such as organic food. A group
of mostly Terrascope alumni is designing a more sustainable and environmentally
sustainable refugee camp, which McCreery describes as having sprung from
Terrascope. "Our advisor is Prof. Franz-Josef Ulm, but the group is from
all different majors. Right now we're mostly doing research to grasp what the
problem really is, and it's a huge problem.
"Before the Amazon trip, I was having a good time with the class, but
Terrascope didn't feel like a cohesive group," noticed McCreery.
"During the trip, everyone bonded. Even though we broke up into two groups
on the trip, and you really bonded with your group, there was still a common
experience. Since it was more cohesive after the trip, we wound up accomplishing
more. We were more efficient because we worked together better in large
groups."
For a complete change of climate, this year's Terrascope freshmen are working as
a team to design the most environmentally correct strategy for oil exploration
and extraction in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. Then they will perform a
cost-benefit analysis to evaluate whether the oil which might be extracted is
worth the environmental damage that might result. In March 2004, they will
travel to Alaska to see what they have been describing for half a year.
"This project-oriented program makes the most out of that refreshing
innocence of the freshmen. Their minds are open and they're willing to try
anything. They may take their time committing, but what they do, they do
completely," says Bras.
web links:
http://web.mit.edu/terrascope/www/
everything about terrascope, from admission to last year's jungle expedition
http://web.mit.edu/terrascope/www/web_pages/photo-album-amazon.html
shows the students exploring, meeting a bat and a caiman, and being amazed by
the rainforest |