NEW CRITIQUES

HOME
SYLLABUS

http://www.hbo.com/city/

Sex in the City
By Sarah Rotman

As opposed to another form of online entertainment I reviewed, Sistas in the City (a take-off of this show), Sex in the City was not made expressly for the web. As a result, the website functions as more of an online appendage to the popular HBO series rather than a fully formed entertainment entity on its own. The content is mostly fluff, and the user comes away thinking this show, and these characters, are more superficial than they thought. Sistas' characters may be comical stereotypes, but at least their website doesn't feature recipes, beauty secrets, advice on dating dilemmas, and the usual beauty magazine quiz. What content there is of the actual show is superficial too-synopses and episode clips in place of the entire episode (but I guess that's all you can give away for free). True, watching an hour-long show, instead of a few minutes of a short format animated show (like Sistas), is an entirely different experience. The Sex in the City website, however, does not even give you the option of downloading an entire episode of Sex, for a fee or no.

Certainly, the most substantial aspect of the Sex in the City website is its online community. (You must register with HBO by giving your email and zip code to participate in discussions.) The user-generated content is a mix of fashion fluff (where can I buy Carrie's aviator sunglasses?), fandom obsession with plot continuity (comparing two similar scenes in which Carrie's suitors ask her the same questions as they complete a crossword puzzle-the fans ask whether the writers are unknowingly plagiarizing themselves if it means something significant about character and plot development), and more substantial "real life" issues (debates around the representation of an interracial relationship on the show). All of this content is interspersed with impassioned pleas for someone to clarify or identify something in a previous episode (what was the poem Carrie read at her friend's wedding in Episode 19 of the 2nd season?) It would make sense that the rest of the site would echo the interest of its users, and not just be a shallow women's e-zine. These viewers want content, not brunch recipes. They are clearly invested in the characters and the plot of the show. I think full episodes for micropayments would be well received on the site, and would be an innovative direction in which to take the site in the future. In addition, the rest of the content on the site should be overhauled to be less superficial and less condescending to the viewer. I don't know what it could be replaced with-actually, the user-generated content by itself, as well as the full episodes available for micro-purchase, would be a convincing enough draw to the site.