CRITIQUE ARCHIVE

HOME   SYLLABUS

http://www.surfnetkids.com/

By Philip Tan

Barbara J. Feldman, a self-professed "computer nerd for over twenty-five years", has established a community around her "Surfing the Net with Kids" syndicated columns. At http://www.surfnetkids.com/, parents find information and get tips for guiding children around the Internet. Although amateurish in appearance, the site employs a 'grassroots' aesthetic that works well with the subject material. Despite its fun and non-threatening visual design, the muted, matter-of-factness of the writing and the site structure establishes that this is a site by parents and for parents, not for kids themselves.

The site does include a well-developed hierarchy of web sites, rated for their kid-appeal, usefulness of information and amount of objectionable material. However, the links are not set up for rapid browsing or comparisons, and is not extremely useful as a search-engine for children who may be interested in finding new sites. Surfnetkids is more useful for parents doing preparatory research (perhaps from workplaces) before actual desk-side time with their children. Compared to the wealth of educational site links, there is surprisingly little information on non-objectionable, simply 'fun' sites for children, although entertaining web site building resources are available from this site.

The most useful feature of Surfnetkids is undoubtedly the Forum, in which parents offer advice to peers to help them with desk-side surfing. The opinions are varied and informative, with many personal anecdotes and experiences that keep a visitor's interest. Barbara Feldman often answers queries personally with useful URLs or snippets of pertinent information, and occasionally she posts polls to get a general idea of prevailing sentiment regarding issues that concern parents and the Internet.

Surfnetkids could stand better development in its link indices, but its chummy aesthetics and community are valuable assets that are important for the future sustainability of the site.