What Is

Beauty?

 

 

 


Introduction

 

Home

 

Beauty

 

Media Representations

 

Life in the Banlieues

 

From Our View

 

Jovonne's In-Depth Analyses

 

Melissa's Personal Observations

 

Acknowledgements

 

Original Proposal

 

Sample of Interview Questions

     The question of physical transformations was one of the most disturbing for us to address and also one of the most complex.  We found the larger issues of beauty norms and self-image to relate particularly to hair and skin shade.  On another level they may also have some effect on the dynamics between Black men and women. 

      We launched a conversation with some of the girls we worked with (both 17-years-old, one from Zaire and the other with African, Arab and Antillean origins), about how most girls wore their hair - typically straightened or with
extensions of various shades, especially blond, red, and light brown.  Their justification of their friends' hairstyles revolved around the manner in which these practices made hair easier to manage.

     Certainly, hair that was relaxed or with extensions was not a new phenomenon for us coming from the US.  Yet, one of our immediate observations on arriving in Paris was the large amount of Black women in particular that wore their hair this way.  The area of the tenth arrondissement in which we lived was well-known as the hub for Black hair and beauty needs.  Living there, it  wasn't long before we began to notice that nearly all of the women leaving the salons left with their hair straightened.  Seldom, if ever, did we saw anyone with hair that was natural - braided, in twists, dreadlocks, or afros.  That in itself was not very surprising as many women these styles do their own hair.  What was surprising however, was the degree of straightening that we saw.  Whether the final style was curled, colored or with extensions it was always straightened to an extent that removed any sense of the thickness and texture that is typically associated with Black hair.  In nearly all cases, the hair was made to look long (extensions and/or wigs) and very much resembled Caucasian hair.   

    Later in our conversation with the girls, they also mentioned the practice of skin bleaching products.  They noted that in spite of the various medical warnings, several of their friends - male and female - used creams and lotions in the hope of lightening their skin. We questioned them regarding what they thought motivated such behavior.  Joanna  answered without hesitation, "Because they think that their skin looks better that way."

     We were troubled and perhaps a bit dissatisfied with both the explanation and its easy acceptance.  We questioned them a bit more to see if they made any association between this trend and
the standards of beauty.  They didn't.  For them, the issue ended there.   As we found no way to further explore the issue without being leading, we ended the
exchange on that particular topic.

     Evidence of skin-bleaching is often in the significant disparity between the color of the skin on a person's face and/or hands as well as their feet, ankles, and knuckles.  Thus in our daily experiences seeing those who participated in the practice was not at all uncommon.  We also saw many of the products on sale, particularly in Black neighborhoods and magazines.  In one, there were more than thirty-five full and half page advertisements focused on skin bleaching products.  This apparent led us to believe that the practice is not only lacking any sort of social taboo, but rather common. 

Occasionally, it is even openly discussed in literature by writers such as Daniel Biyaoula, who show that it  is often a matter on which those who practice it pride themselves.  Similarly, the friends of the girls we interviewed openly talked about their activities.  
     Like the straightening of hair, skin bleaching could easily be seen as a means of achieving "beauty" within the context of a Eurocentric paradigm.  However, this practice was especially disturbing, perhaps because it considerably more difficult to attribute it to any practical concern.  The use of extensions or wigs and even the relaxing of hair could be considered acts of convenience.  Relaxing is claimed to make hair more manageable by making it easier to comb and style. Similarly wearing wigs or extensions may take the strain off of hair from combing and styling, while at the same time requiring little in the manner of upkeep.  We could find no such an explanation for skin bleaching - it seems simply to be a matter of beauty.  Furthermore, it not only does it serve no practical benefit, but it also does nearly irreparable damage to the skin. Still it continues and its message, especially in light of its harmful qualities, seems painfully clear - lighter is better.

     Reaching an understanding in the phenomena of skin bleaching and Eurocentric hairstyles, according to us, requires looking at several issues outside of the concerned women themselves.  As previously mentioned, the media plays a predominant role.  Person after person we interviewed complained about the lack of adequate representation of people of color in the popular media -news reports, movies, game shows, etc.  Yet, they made no mention of the standards of beauty diffused by the media when people of color - particularly women -were depicted.  

    Over the course of the summer, we remarked that much as was once the norm in the US, the beauty of the black women was equated with light skin and long, straight hair.  On the covers of magazines as well as in ads and articles we saw, a grand majority of the women shared these two characteristics.  In the same manner that media norms of ultra-skinny women have been shown to impact women's conception of their body image and body size, we believe that these representations of black women impact their definition of beauty and their conception of their skin color.

     Our observation have also led us to believe that the dynamics between black men and women in Paris may also play a role in this situation. The relationship between black men and women can be
strained, with black men deeming black women to be too demanding and difficult, both emotionally and financially, and thus opting for relationships with white women. In a situation where black women are frequently competing against white
women while observing the black men's preferences, they might alter themselves in an effort to meet men's expectations, particularly to look like their white counterparts.  It is difficult to assess whether this is effectively the case our observations on physical transformations has made such theory at least plausible.

   

MIT Homepage  |   Eloranta Home   |   Project Home

Project Proposal |   AcknowledgementsComments