An International Conference
October 8-10, 1999
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
The Changing Face of News
Moderator: Robert Kanigel
Public
Address and the Time Frequency of Writing
John
Hartley, Cardiff University
Modes of public communication,
ranging from journalism to architecture, can be understood not only in
relation to space (their geographical setting) but also in relation to
time. 'Public address' of different kinds has a frequency, from the (high-frequency)
instant to the (low-frequency) millennium. This paper explores some of
the implications of analysing public 'writing' in terms of its frequency,
and considers how changes in frequency, in journalism especially, may affect
the cultural form and public understanding of the medium in question. The
relations between spatial and temporal aspects of public communication
are discussed, and comparisons made between 'writing' of different frequencies,
including journalism (high frequency), academic and scholarly writing (mid
frequency) and public architecture (low frequency). |
Hypertext
and Journalism:
Audiences Respond
to Competing News Narratives
Robert
Huesca and Brenda Dervin, Trinity University
[The complete text of this Robert Huesca's and Brenda Dervin's paper is available.]
The advent of new communication technologies has generated a robust and provocative research literature examining the implications of hypertext on the conventions of writing. The nature of online narratives are summarized to be, among other things,
nonlinear, fragmented, participatory, in flux, impermanent, and designed
to change. On the whole, these characteristics challenge accepted notions
of "good writing" and of narrative conventions across genres. For the genre
of print journalism, these challenges to textual norms also have implications
for reporting practices. This paper reports on a study of the viability
of the hypertext form for journalism. The study asked readers to compare
a conventional, online news article with a redesigned, hypertext version
of it. Following basic hypertext design principles, a team of researchers
reformatted linear news features published by the Los
Angeles Times. A group of 20 volunteers was then asked to read
one of the articles, comparing the original version to the hypertext. Following
the reading exercise, qualitative interviews were conducted to explore
responses to the competing narrative forms. This paper is based on an analysis
of the transcripts of these 20 interviews. The findings reinforce some
traditional values and routines of the press, but also suggest an expansion
of the roles, functions, and practices of journalists. Readers were split
evenly among those who voiced a strong preference for hypertext or for
linear narratives. A large number of readers noted that each form had advantages
and disadvantages, and that preference for one form over the other depended
on reading context and purpose. Finally, some of the reasons given for
disliking hypertexts cited features that have been described as their inherent
characteristics (fragmentation, absence of authorial voice). |
Newer
Technologies versus Older Mediums:
Can Newspapers Survive?
Tiffany Townsend Fessler,
Morton Vardeman & Carlson
This case study explores
the impact of newer technologies on newspaper coverage, specifically looking
at the introduction of television into the media mix in the 1952 presidential
nominating conventions and the introduction of the Internet into the mix
in the 1998 Starr report. The research indicates change does occur in the
older medium's coverage, both suddenly and over a period of time, though
it does not indicate this change has a negative effect on newspapers. |
|