Yay, a puzzle for all the bronies out there! (You know who you are!)
First, identify the ponies and the human celebrities:
| Applejack | Vanessa Hudgens |
| Daring Do | Avril Lavigne |
| Fancy Pants | Ariana Grande |
| Fleur Dis Lee | Ben Affleck |
| Flitter | Sam Rockwell |
| Fluttershy | David Duchovny |
| Holly Dash | Sarah Michelle Gellar |
| Mrs. Cake | Joan Jett |
| Ms. Peachbottom | Eve |
| Princess Luna | Jenny McCarthy |
| Rose | Jerry Lawler |
| Sea Swirl | Ginnifer Goodwin |
| Shoeshine | Hayley Atwell |
| Zecora | Scarlett Johansson |
| Zipporwhill | Katy Perry |
As it turns out, each human has a cutie mark, er, tattoo, that matches one of the given ponies. Move the ponies around to match their human, and index into the pony's name.
| CELEBRITY | TATTOO/CUTIE MARK | PONY | INDEX | LETTER |
| Vanessa Hudgens | Butterfly | Fluttershy | (1 | F |
| Avril Lavigne | Cupcake | Mrs. Cake | (5) | A |
| Ariana Grande | Moon | Princess Luna | (10) | U |
| Ben Affleck | Dolphin | Sea Swirl | (4) | S |
| Sam Rockwell | Rooster/Chicken | Ms. Peachbottom | (11) | T |
| David Duchovny | Compass | Daring Do | (6) | G |
| Sarah Michelle Gellar | Dragonfly | Flitter | (3) | I |
| Joan Jett | Spiral "Sun" | Zecora | (5) | R |
| Eve | Pawprint | Zipporwhill | (10) | L |
| Jenny McCarthy | Rose | Rose | (3) | S |
| Jerry Lawler | Crown | Fancy Pants | (6) | P |
| Ginnifer Goodwin | Apple | Applejack | (4) | L |
| Hayley Atwell | Fleur-de-lis | Fleur Dis Lee | (4) | U |
| Scarlett Johansson | Horseshoe | Shoeshine | (1) | S |
| Katy Perry | Strawberry | Holly Dash | (6) | D |
The extraction message is FAUST GIRLS PLUS D. Lauren Faust, the creator of the modern MLP show, is also known for Powerpuff Girls. The answer is POWDERPUFF.