by TK Focht
Answer: SMASHING PUMPKINS
Problem: April Fool’s Day

This puzzle consists of twenty-one songs, all of which are roughly in common meter: four lines, with the first and third in iambic tetrameter (eight syllables) and the second and fourth in iambic trimeter (six syllables). Because they all have roughly the same meter, they can all be sung to each other’s melodies. This melodic substitution is somewhat well-known for “Amazing Grace,” “The House of the Rising Sun,” and “The Ballad of Gilligan’s Isle.”

No lyric in this puzzle is sung to its proper melody. Instead, the lyrics and melodies have been crossed over each other, and the resulting lines have been strung together. Each line also corresponds with a given letter. If solvers align these letters so that the corresponding melodies are sung correctly from left to right and each corresponding set of lyrics is sung correctly from top to bottom, the result is the repeating grid shown below.

Many of the songs are missing one line, forming empty intersections of words. Each intersection can be filled by one letter to form two uncapitalized English words. These intersections are shown in yellow and bold in the grid. The inserted letters spell SMASHING PUMPKINS, which is the answer to the puzzle.

Truly Madly Deeply
Escape (The Piña Colada Song)
The Yellow Rose of Texas
I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing
Oh! Susanna
Battle Hymn of the Republic
God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
Marines’ Hymn
Semper Paratus
The Rains of Castamere
I Just Can’t Wait to Be King
Material Girl
Can’t Buy Me Love
The House of the Rising Sun
America the Beautiful
Come Sail Away
The Ballad of Gilligan’s Isle
Mickey Mouse March
Advance Australia Fair
Pokémon Theme Song
Amazing Grace
JERK
PUMP
RISE
WENT
FISTCome Sail Away
WANTI’d Like to Teach the World to Sing
SAIDBattle Hymn of the Republic
TOLLMarines’ Hymn
SOAKI Just Can’t Wait to Be King
DUMPMaterial Girl
COMBThe Rains of Castamere
OUZOAmazing Grace
EPEEOh! Susanna
ODESGod Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
SIGNPokémon Theme Song
LANEEscape (The Piña Colada Song)
SILKAdvance Australia Fair
WHETThe Yellow Rose of Texas
MAIDThe Ballad of Gilligan’s Isle
WASPTruly Madly Deeply
MASHThe House of the Rising Sun
JERKMickey Mouse March
PUMPAmerica the Beautiful
RISECan’t Buy Me Love
WENTSemper Paratus