Sem083: Ethics in Cyberspace
Assignment #6: MIT Notables: Richard Stallman & David LaMacchia
Steven Levy's book Hackers concludes with a chapter entitled : The
Last of the True Hackers. He is referring to
Richard Stallman, inventor of the EMACS editor, creator of the GNU
operating system and founder of the Free
Software Foundation.
Read at least one of the following of his articles:
In April 1994, MIT junior David LaMacchia was indicted for conspiracy to commit
wire fraud, based on the accusation that he had modified an Athena workstation
to allow people on the network to use it to download copyrighted software without
paying. The case received national notoriety, the US Attorney in Boston calling
it the largest incident of software piracy ever. In December 1994, the charges
against LaMacchia were dismissed, with the judge ruling that copyright infringement
can not be prosecuted under the wire fraud statute. The case raises important
issues about liability of system operators and about the scope of computer crime
and copyright laws.
Source documents:
News articles
Needless to say, there was a lot of media coverage both at MIT and elsewhere regarding
this case. Read the ones marked **** * as well as any others that interest you.
Most are brief.
- April 7, 1994 (Associated Press)
Student Faces Software Charges
- April 8, 1994 (Reuters)
Computer Whiz Indicted
- April 9, 1994 (The Tech)
Student Indicted on Piracy Charges
- April 10, 1994 ,
Computer Case Raises Questions"
- April 12,1994 (The Tech)
LaMacchia Will Be Arraigned Friday
- April 12,1994 (The Tech)
Editorial- Software Piracy A Serious Crime
- April 13, 1994
Harvey Silverglate: Letter to the Boston Globe
- April 15, 1994(The Tech)
Piracy Case May Set Precedent *****
- April 22, 1994 (The Tech) LaMacchia
Case Raises Legal Questions of Fraud
- Oct. 14, 1994 (The Tech)
Lawyers File Pre-Trial Motion to Dismiss LaMacchia Case
- Nov. 15, 1994 (The Tech)
Gov't Opposes Motion to Dismiss LaMacchia Case
- Nov. 22, 1994 (The Tech)
Judge Considering LaMacchia Motion
- Dec. 29, 1994 (Reuters)
Judge Dismisses Indictment Against Mit Computer Whiz
*****
- Jan. 11, 1995 (The Tech)
Judge Dismisses Case against LaMacchia *****
- February 7, 1995 (The
Tech) David LaMacchia cleared; case raises civil liberties issues
- March, 1995 (Internet World)
"No CopyCat Criminal: LaMacchia case reveals a federal attitude problem"
by Mike Godwin ******
- Spring, 1995 (Time Magazine)
Cops on the I-Way, by Mike Godwin
Questions to ponder:
- What does Richard mean by "free" software?
- In dismissing the charges against David LaMacchia, U.S. District Court Judge
Richard Stearns described LaMacchia as ` "heedlessly irresponsible, and
at worst as nihilistic, self-indulgent and lacking in any fundamental sense
of values.'' Do you agree with his statement?
- What do you think Richard would say about David's activities?