|
The James T. Koetting Prize is the Northeast Chapter's award for the
outstanding graduate student paper presented at the annual chapter meeting.
Here are a few past winners:
2002
Stephen Pixley, Wesleyan University, " Performance as Ethnographic Object:
Musical Images of the Primitive in Hill Tribe Tourism"(abstract)
2001
Birgit Berg, Smith College, " The Kidung Jemaat: A Christian Hymnal in
a Non-Christian World"(abstract)
2000
Susan Thomas's "The Transformation of the Black Man in the Cuban Zarzuela" treats
issues of race and gender in a minstrel-related repertory of Cuba,
making comparisons to the United States.
1999
Judith Casselberry of Wesleyan University won the 1999 prize for her
paper, entitled "The Living Dead
and Spirits: Inspiration and Guidance for Black Women in Popular American
Music," (abstract)
1998
Robin Carruthers, M.A. candidate at Tufts University, won the 1998 prize for her paper entitled "CalamC: Characteristics of Lullaby in Venezuela." (abstract)
1996
Timothy J. Cooley, a Ph.D. candidate at Brown University, was
awarded the 1996 Prize for his paper entitled "Authenticity on Trial
in Polish Contest Festivals." (abstract)
1992
Patrick Hutchinson, a graduate student at Brown University, won the
1992 Prize for his paper, "Hand-Made Music: An Uilleann Pipers's Way with Words."
Stephen Pixley, Wesleyan University.
" Performance as Ethnographic Object: Musical Images of the Primitive in
Hill Tribe Tourism."
Based upon recent fieldwork, this paper examines the performed display of upland
ethnic minority cultures (hilltribes) for tourists in the mountains of Northern
Thailand, and the use of music in crafting images of primitivism. Case studies
of three varieties of staged culture shows will demonstrate how dichotomous aspects
of the Primitive saturate hill tribe tourism. While hilltribe tourism's performative
nature has been widely discussed, especially in Erik Cohen's theory of communicative
staging, this paper addresses the specific contribution of music to tourism
narratives. Culture shows at mass-audience venues utilize musical strategies
of simplification, ethnic cross-dressing, superficial glossing, and the conflation
of unrelated ethnic groups to perpetuate a savage and undeveloped image, thereby
achieving an impoverishment of both the sound and meaning of hilltribe music,
and ultimately a musical silencing of their subjects.
Borrowing from Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett's analysis of how museum objects
become ethnographic through processes of detachment and contextualization, the
second part of this paper theorizes that hilltribe music and dance within the
khantoke dinner show do not function as concert performances, but rather as ethnographic
objects fulfilling expectations of the tribal primitive, and illustrating the
narrative of the Thai nation. The same primitivizing musical strategies that
serve to detach hilltribe music from its musical roots, also serve to recontextualize
it within the khantoke show's narrative of how hilltribes and Northern Thais
differ from each other in the national imagination.
Birgit Berg, Smith College.
"The Kidung Jemaat: A Christian Hymnal in a Non-Christian World"
Although it is the largest Muslim nation in the world, Indonesia is the home
to a number of diverse Christian communities. In an attempt to unite these
communities the Indonesian Council of Churches (I.C.C.) sponsored a program
to "scientifically study several indigenous Indonesian music system and
their potential for being utilized in and by the Church" (Cooley 1981).
A decade later, the I.C.C. published a Christian hymnal, the Kidung Jemaat.
This hymnal contains over 100 hymns written by Indonesians, some in indigenous
styles, but it also contains hymns from a variety of countries, cultures, and
denominations. Hymns in the Kidung Jemaat can be traced to the Lutheran, Calvinist,
and Anabaptist traditions of Europe and America, as well as to cultures and
communities in such places as India, Zambia, and Sri Lanka. The aim of this
paper is to investigate the Kidung Jemaat; the styles, forms, and traditions
found in its contents; its use in everyday worship; and its background, including
a look into the history of Christian conversion in Indonesia and the role conversion
played in the promotion and demotion of indigenous arts in the Church.
Judith Casselberry of Wesleyan University won
the 1999 prize for her paper, entitled "The Living Dead and Spirits:
Inspiration and Guidance for Black Women in Popular American Music."
Spiritual text by African-American women recording artist has most
often been examined in the context of the Christian spirituals. However,
Black
womens spiritual text exists in many musical genres, and outside
of conventional constructs of hierarchical modes of religion and worship.
This paper explores examples of traditional West African cosmologies
and ontologies an African sacred world viewapparent in original
lyrical text by African-American women. Particular attention is given
to the roles of the living dead and spirits in the work of Bernice Johnson
Reagon, historian, activist, and founder of the internationally renowned,
womens a cappella group Sweet Honey in the Rock, and Blue Note
label, jazz vocalist Dianne Reeves.
A distinction between spirits and the living dead is made in West and
Central African cosmology, and other Black Atlantic belief systems.
Utilizing field research, personal interviews, and song text analysis,
I explore how this distinction is manifest in the work of these two
contemporary Black women artists.
Robin Carruthers, "CalamC: Characteristics of Lullaby in Venezuela."
The paper contains information regarding research in Venezuela
between September and December of 1997. The research focused on obtaining
examples of lullabies from Barlovento, a region of the state of Miranda.
This paper covers historical information on lullabies in general, origins
and influences on the lullabies, and textual and musical analysis of the
lullabies. Prior work on lullabies considered the common textual and
musical characteristics of lullabies from different regions of the world
(USA, Turkey, Indonesia, and South India). I use this group of similar
elements when analyzing the lullaby collected from Barlovento. I chose one
of the fifteen lullabies, "CalamC)", to provide an example of my analytic
process.
Timothy Cooley, "Authenticity on Trial in Polish Contest Festivals."
Song and dance troupes and contest festivals have been part of the
cultural landscape since the Second World War in "Podhale", the Tatra
mountain region of Poland. Festival performances and their larger context
of tourism are part of the metamorphoses of Podhale from an isolated and
avoided mountain region into a major tourist destination. A prominent
feature of a contest festival is a jury of folklorists, ethnomusicologists,
dance ethnologists, and other cultural experts who judge performing
"folkloric" troupes on the basis of "authenticity." The music, dance,
costumes, and local dialect presented on the festival stage are
entertainment to some, and highly symbolic to others. To many "Górale"
(mountaineers from Podhale), the festival performance is a carefully
crafted public statement of ethnic identity-identity that is in dialogue
with multiple constructions of the "authentic."
Recent writings in ethnomusicology, anthropology and folklore
recognize the interdependence between the industries of heritage, tourism
and ethnography. In this paper, I focus on one intersection of these
industries-the festival performance. My research reveals that Górale
musicians and dancers perform in response to, and sometimes in resistance
to, the notions of authenticity valued in a festival setting. Based on
field research in Poland conducted since 1992, this presentation shows the
impact of festival performances and their supporting industries of
heritage, tourism, and ethnography on Górale, Górale music culture, and on
Górale ethnic identity.
|