by Avram Gottschlich
Answer: ICONOGRAPHY
Problem: Halloween Town/​Thanksgiving Town

Step one is identifying the badges. They come from four different sources (Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, Untappd, and Sporcle). A full list can be found below. The first letters spell out CHOOSING DIFFERENT SHADES FOR EACH BADGE TYPE SHOWS A MESSAGE FOR HOW TO COMPLETE THIS.

Coloring the four sources of badges different colors (BSA in green, Untappd in blue, GSA in yellow, and Sporcle in white), we get:

ONLY W/ N, indicating to take only the badges with Ns in their names. Doing this, we get:

This is Braille for ICONOGRAPHY, the answer to the puzzle.




Badge list colored by source (BSA green, Untappd blue, GSA yellow, Sporcle white):

Chess Horsemanship Oceanography On With the Show Summer Fun I’ll Be Bock Night Owl Goal-Oriented
Digital Technology I Like Pi Forestry Fruits of Your Labor Early Bird Raising the Heat Eco Advocate N.E.W.T. Levels
Traffic Safety Scholarship Home Repairs Ahoy Matey Deal or New Deal East Coast Brew Crawl Space Science Investigator Field Day
On My Own Ready to Rumble Entrepreneur Age of Badge-lightenment Crouching Tiger, Hidden Badge Hail to the Chief Badge, I’m Madonna Arcade Addict
Detective Game Visionary Eating for You Take a Dunk! You Go Glen Coco Pole Position Earth Day So Udderly Sweet
Health Nut Outdoor Art Master War Games Six Pack All American Merry Brewmas (2011) Elite Swedish Brews
Shaken, Not Stirred Alexander Badgilton Genealogy Euro-Trip Frequent Flyer Outdoor Adventurer Room Makeover Hiker
One Small Step Woodwork That’s No Moon Orange Aura Call of the Wild Outdoor Art Apprentice Marvelous Meryl Photographer
Landscape Architecture EGOT Taco Tuesday Eureka Think Outside the Box(ing) Day Home Scientist Is This the Real Life? Sky

Sources:

Badges with Ns:

Chess Horsemanship Oceanography On With the Show Summer Fun I’ll Be Bock Night Owl Goal-Oriented
Digital Technology I Like Pi Forestry Fruits of Your Labor Early Bird Raising the Heat Eco Advocate N.E.W.T. Levels
Traffic Safety Scholarship Home Repairs Ahoy Matey Deal or New Deal East Coast Brew Crawl Space Science Investigator Field Day
On My Own Ready to Rumble Entrepreneur Age of Badge-lightenment Crouching Tiger, Hidden Badge Hail to the Chief Badge, I’m Madonna Arcade Addict
Detective Game Visionary Eating for You Take a Dunk! You Go Glen Coco Pole Position Earth Day So Udderly Sweet
Health Nut Outdoor Art Master War Games Six Pack All American Merry Brewmas (2011) Elite Swedish Brews
Shaken, Not Stirred Alexander Badgilton Genealogy Euro-Trip Frequent Flyer Outdoor Adventurer Room Makeover Hiker
One Small Step Woodwork That’s No Moon Orange Aura Call of the Wild Outdoor Art Apprentice Marvelous Meryl Photographer
Landscape Architecture EGOT Taco Tuesday Eureka Think Outside the Box(ing) Day Home Scientist Is This the Real Life? Sky