Weblog

SPACE AND TIME: Part 1E

PART 1E: Minkowski's words are in **boldface**.

To recapitulate: in the old, unchanged coordinates, we had an
ordinary hyperbola, *c² t² - x²* = 1.
Then we tilted the *t*-axis away from the vertical,
and called the coordinate associated with this new axis *t′*.
In the skewed
coordinate-system *x, t′*, the equation of the hyperbola is
some ugly and complicated expression depending on the angle of tilt.
To remedy this, we bend the *x*-axis *up* from the horizontal.
The result is not a clockwise rotation of the two axes, but a scissor-like motion;
the axes move against each other. (In the Twentieth Century a motion of this
type involving the time axis will be called a "boost".)
But the new coordinates *x′,
t′* (with the unpleasant complication of a
special scale choice) describe the hyperbola by
*c² t′² - x′²* = 1, looking just like the
unprimed case.
*c*.
Although Minkowski does not stress the point, later writers will
emphasise that *c* is a "conversion factor" which
guarantees that *t* and the space coordinates have the same units.
If the space coordinates are measured in centimeters and time
is measured in seconds, *c* must have units "centimeters
per second" so that *ct* is a distance.

Graphic by Miss MJ

**"We now add to these transformations all arbitrary shiftings
of the space and time origin, and in this way construct a group
of transformations obviously still dependent on the parameter
c, which I designate by G(c)."**

G(*c*) is then the set of

- all rotations of the space axes
- all scissor-like "boosts" involving the time axis
- all translations of the origin

**"If we now let c increase to infinity, 1/c thus converging
to zero, we see from the figure described that the branch of the
hyperbola always approaches closer to the x-axis, and the
angle between the asymptotes widens into a straight angle."**

The equation of the hyperbola is *c² t² - x²* = 1.
The coordinates of point A are therefore (*x*=0, *ct*=1), or,
equivalently, (*x*=0, *t*=1/*c*). The coordinates of
point B are therefore (*x*=1, *t*=1/c), and those of
point C are (*x*=1, *t*=0). As *c* becomes larger
and larger, 1/*c* becomes smaller and smaller, so point A
approaches the origin, point B approaches point C, and the hyperbola
looks more and more like a straight line -- in fact, like the
*x*-axis itself.

**"At the limit
the special transformation changes into one in which the
t′-axis can have any upward direction and x′
steadily approaches nearer to x. "**

Think about how *x′* and *t′*
change as the distance OA goes to zero.

**"In consequence of this,
it is clear that the group G( c) in the limit for c=∞,
(thus as the group G(∞)), becomes the complete group of
Newton's mechanics."**

Using Twentieth-Century language: Minkowski's metric space-time
geometry becomes Newton's space-time fibre-bundle when *c* goes
to infinity. Newtonian mechanics is then a *limiting case* of some
more general kind of mechanics.

**"Under these circumstances, and since G( c) is mathematically
more intelligible than G(∞) ... "**

More intelligible because it is finite. Although the situation is changing a bit in 1908, mathematicians remain uneasy about infinities.

**"Under these circumstances, and since G( c) is mathematically
more intelligible than G(∞), a mathematician in the free play of
his imagination might well have had the idea that, after all, the phenomena
of nature do not actually remain invariant for the group G(∞), but
rather for a group G(c) with a c that is definite and finite
but very large if taken in the ordinary units.
**

**
"Such an idea would have been an extraordinary triumph of pure mathematics.
Now, although mathematics has here been caught napping, she still has the
satisfaction that, owing to her happy antecedents, through senses
made keen by their exercise in broad vistas, she is capable of grasping
at once the far-reaching consequences of such a transformation
of our conception of nature."**

Einstein had taken classes from Minkowski at ETH. One can imagine
how the (slightly) older mathematician must have felt in 1905: "Why didn't I
think of that?" Perhaps he *did* think of it; he is supposed to
have told Max Born that he had done so, not publishing because he
wanted first to develop a fuller mathematical picture like the one in *Raum und
Zeit*.
But although Einstein *found* special relativity,
and many people came close to finding it or perhaps would have found it
eventually, only Minkowski understood just how amazing a thing had been
found. Einstein's
derivation involved (as in the title of his famous paper) "the electrodynamics
of moving bodies"; his was a physicist's derivation, based on reasoning
about light and motion. Minkowski, as a mathematician, recognised that
this was needlessly restrictive and complicated; special relativity is not
about physics, but about the geometry of space and time. It is about the
very nature of reality.

Einstein was initially taken aback by the four-dimensional interpretation, but he quickly changed his mind (in part through the influence of Minkowski's friend David Hilbert) and made it the basis of his entire subsequent approach to physics. Without doing so, he would probably never have arrived at the far more abstract and original general theory of relativity a few years later, an astonishing achievement which no-one else but Hilbert came close to anticipating, and which remains strangely underappreciated even today.

**"I shall now indicate what value of c will finally come into consideration.
For c we shall substitute the term velocity of light in a vacuum.
In order to avoid the terms 'space' and 'void' we can define this magnitude as
the ratio between the electromagnetic and electrostatic units of electric
quantity."**

Electromagnetism has always been plagued by disagreements over units. Two once-popular systems, electromagnetic cgs and electrostatic cgs, employ rival units of charge which differ by a factor of the speed of light. There is a much deeper significance to this, however. The electrostatic system of units is based ultimately on Coulomb's law of the attraction between charges; the electromagnetic system on Ampere's law of the attraction between current-carrying wires. Each of these force laws contains an empirical, experimentally-measured constant in the other system of units. That the ratio of these two constants is the square of the speed of light was a surprise, and a major factor in the acceptance of Maxwell's theory. The use of electromagnetic methods to measure the speed of light was proposed jointly by Maxwell and the unjustly-forgotten Fleeming Jenkin in 1863; Minkowski may know that one of the best attempts to achieve this has just been made at the US Bureau of Standards.

**"The existence of the invariance of natural laws for the group G( c) under
consideration would now be derived as follows:
**

**
"From the totality of natural phenomena we can derive with ever increasing
exactitude by successively closer and closer approximations, a system of
reference x, y, z, and t, space and time, in terms of
which these phenomena are then represented according to definite laws.
But this system of reference is by no means uniquely determined thereby.
It is still possible to change this system of reference at will, corresponding to
the transformations of the above mentioned group G(c), without
changing thereby the expression of natural laws.
**

**
"For example, according to the described figure, we can also call t′ the
time, but then in connection with it we must necessarily define space by
the manifold of the three parameters x′ y, z, in which case
physical laws would be expressed in terms of x′, y, z, t′,
exactly the same as in terms of x, y, z, t. According to this there
would be in the world not that particular space but an infinite number of spaces,
just as there is an infinite number of planes in three-dimensional space.
**

**
"Three-dimensional geometry becomes a chapter of four-dimensional physics.
You now understand why I said at the outset that space and time are to
fade away into mere shadows and that only a world-in-itself will exist."**

Next: Part 2 -- Mathematics into Physics

Graphic by Miss MJ

TIME AND SPACE, by Hermann Minkowski