VI. Hydroelectric Power

 

A. Introduction

 

There are four main divisions of hydroelectric power plants: 1) micro-scale, 2) small-scale, 3) large-scale, 4) run-of-the-river, and 5) pumped storage.

Micro-scale plants are capable of producing one kilowatt to one megawatt of power.  They are typically used for small, isolated villages in developing countries.

Small-scale plants are capable of producing up to twenty megawatts of power.  These systems are relatively inexpensive to implement.  They can be used in developing countries to provide electricity to rural areas.

Large-scale plants are the most efficient type of hydroelectric power plant.  They are typically constructed by damning a river to form a lake.   The largest hydroelectric power plant in the world[1] produces 12.6 GW of electricity, with an annual rate of 90 million MW hours.  Large-scale plants take advantage of the potential energy of flowing water due to gravity to extrapolate energy.

Run-of-the-river hydroelectric plants work on the principle that the flow rate and elevation drops of the water are consistent enough that hydroelectric plants can be built directly in the river. The water passes through the plant without greatly changing the flow rate of the river. In many instances a dam is not required, and therefore the hydroelectric plant causes minimal environmental impact on its surroundings.

Pumped storage plants are used to provide peak power production during peak power usage times. During non-peak times, water is pumped back into an upper reservoir for peak time usage.

 

B. Power Production

 

Power production at given time is related to two factors: 1) flow volume, and 2) head.  Head is a measure of the pressure of falling water.  Rivers can be roughly divided into having either high or low[2] head.  Hydroelectric production on rivers with less than two feet of vertical drop is unfeasible.  The higher the head, the more efficient hydroelectric power production will be.  Although high volume can compensate for low head, a more costly turbine to produce convert the energy to electricity will be necessary.

A simple formula for power is outlined below.  It shows power dependent on gross head (H) and flow (F), as well as system efficiency (E), which typically ranges from 40-70%, and a constant (C) that is dependent on the particular unit system being used (U.S. Department of Energy, 2001).

 

Text Box: Equation 11




C. Effects

 

Hydroelectric Dams affect the river in the following ways:

  1.  Create water reservoirs/stagnant pools
    • Become breeding groups for malaria and other diseases
    • Higher water temperatures with little or no monthly variation
  2. Increased flooding
  3. Decreased residence time (fill with sediment)
  4. Increased Eutrophication
  5. Increased formation of methane gas
  6. Corrosion of equipment
  7. Decreased water quality downstream
  8. Increased water temperature
  9. Decreased water oxygen content
  10. Increased siltation
  11. Increased phosphorous and nitrogen content
  12. Impact on fish populations
  13. Energy transmission systems also have a negative impact on the environment

Damned rivers can be divided into four main segments: 1) an upstream segment, 2) the segment immediately behind the damn, 3) the segment immediately downstream of the damn, and 4) the segment downstream of the dam.   The upstream segment of the river is largely unaffected by the dam.   The segment of the river most affected by the dam is the portion directly downstream of the dam.  In this section native fish population are the most severely affected, to the point that the population may be dominated by non-native species.  With increasing distance from the dam, and with the influx of other rivers and streams, the affect of the dam becomes less severe.  Correspondingly, native fish populations are more successful with this increasing distance (Brown et al, 2002).  Fish populations which migrate each year upstream to spawn are particularly affected by damning.  One simple solution for this is the construction of fish ladders, which provide pathways for fish to navigate past damns (Energy Matters, 1998).

Reservoirs have both positive and negative effects on the upstream and downstream environments due to the modification of the natural flow conditions. These effects include higher temperatures, with little to no variation in temperature throughout the course of a year; increased forest flooding, critical situation in reservoir filling (from the sediment dropped when the water slows in the reservoir), decreased residence time, increased eutrophication, increased gas formation, corrosion of equipment and a decline in the water quality downstream.  One possible solution that would negate these negative effects is hydraulic equipment to reaerate reservoirs ("Water Quality Simulation in Reservoirs in the Amazon Basin: Preliminary Analysis" by Carlos Eduardo Morelli Tucci. From Water Management of the Amazon Basin).

D. Comparison
 

Table 12: Comparison of means of power generation in Brazil

Hydropower and Electricity

·  Installed electric capacity of 68.8 million kilowatts, 87% hydropower (2000)

·  342.3 billion kilowatt-hours generated in 2000, in 2000: 89% hydropower; in 1999: 91% hydropower

·  One of world's top hydropower producers

·  Brazil's small northern and larger southern electrical grids joined in January 1999 into one grid that serves 98% of the country 

·  See effects above (Part C)

 

Oil

·  Second largest oil reserves in South America (after Venezuela) at 8.4 billion barrels

·  Production 1.6 million barrels per day in 2001

·  Oil consumption almost 2.2 million barrels per day in 2001

·  Imports from mostly Venezuela and Argentina

·  Combustion results in sulfur and nitrogen impurities, pollution and green house effect.

Natural Gas

·  Production and consumption rose steadily throughout the 1990's

·  Imports beginning in 1999

·  Natural gas reserves as of January 2002 at 7.8 trillion cubic feet

·  Fifth largest in South America behind Venezuela, Argentina, Bolivia, and Peru

·  More efficient and more economical than some coal and nuclear plants

·  “20% of total CO2 emissions from fossil fuels in 1996 came from consuming and flaring natural gas. Natural gas emissions increased 26.9% from 1987 to 1996, the U.S. and Russia accounting for a whopping 42% of the world total” (International Energy Annual)

Coal

·  Brazil's recoverable coal reserves are estimated approximately 13.2 billion short tons of lignite and sub-bituminous coal, giving it the largest coal reserves in Latin America

·  Due to high ash and sulfur content and low caloric value of domestic coal, Brazil imports a significant amount of cal

·  ~6.8 million short tons produced in 2000

·  Consumption about 23.5 million short tons 

·  Emissions include sulfur oxides, nitrogen oxides, organic compounds, heavy metals, radioactive elements, and ash

 

Nuclear Energy

·  Electronuclear

·  2 operational nuclear plants, Angra-1 and Angra-2

·  1 under construction, Angra-3

·  On hold, however electricity crisis may restart it, estimated 5 years to become operational

·  Nuclear Program came under Ministry of Defense rather than Ministry of Mines and Energy

·  Decrease in military funding meant delays in nuclear power plant construction

·  Government company, to assume responsibility for the plants

·  Non-renewable energy

·  Final disposal of radioactive waste

·  In Angra-1:

·  -High levels of shutdowns

·  -Radiation spills

Ethanol and other biomass

·  Sugar Cane Industry

·  Came as result of oil shock of 1973

·  Generates more than 4,000 gigawatt hours annually to run its own refineries and distilleries

·  Has excess capacity of 200 MW

·  Produces between 3.4 and 3.7 billion gallons of ethanol for automobiles per year

·  Could contribute to global warming

·  1975:  Brazilian National Alcohol Program created to regulate ethanol market and encourage production and use of fuel ethanol

Wind turbines (Energy Matters, 1998).

·  Current total capacity of only 20MW

·  Further 25MW are to come on line in the north-eastern Ceara state, where trade winds are strong

·  Large numbers of turbines required to produce significant amounts of electricity

·  Larger impact on environment

·  Minimum wind speed

·  Small: 8 mi/hr

·  Large: 13 mi/hr

·  Large areas of land needed

·  Land can also be used for agriculture

·  High cost relative to production of energy

·  Only generate energy 25% of time

·  Completely renewable source of energy

·  Safe

 

Next: Conclusion  -->

 


 



[1] Itaipú hydroelectric power plant  on the Paraná River

[2]  Vertical drop < 10ft