Write an assessment for each of the student's concepts, considering the idea potential, embodiment/implementation direction, user experience and human factors, clarity of the sketches, and the client requirements (as outlined in the concept sketches description).

When making comments, be sure to enter your comments in the area indicated for the concept sketch that you are critiquing. The concepts may be listed in a different order than how they are listed in the website. There is a single field at the bottom of the form for commenting on the presentation and clarity of all the concepts.

See the concept sketches critique description for additional information about this on-line review process.

As always, when you have critical comments, it is essential to provide constructive suggestions on how to improve the work. All reviews will be made available on the course website but, as a reviewer, you will remain anonymous.