SOLUTIONS
This page is a work in progress which
contains some ideas that we have been developing for final development strategies.
When it is finished, it will give our final plan for how to address
problems of sustainable and environmental development in the Brazilian Amazon.
SUSTAINABLE MINING:
Preliminary readout
of fairly specific techniques in sustainable mining:
- Economic sphere:
- maximize human well-being
- ensure efficient use of all
resources, natural and otherwise, by maximizing rents
- seek to identify and internalize
environmental and social costs
- maintain and enhance the conditions
for viable enterprise
- Social sphere:
- ensure a fair distribution
of the costs and benefits of development for all those alive today
- respect and reinforce the
fundamental rights of human beings, including civil and personal security
- seek to sustain improvements
over time; ensure that depletion of natural resources will not deprive future
generations through replacement with other forms of capital
-Environmental sphere:
- promote responsible stewardship
of natural resources and the environment, including remediation for past
damage
- encourage free enterprise
within a system of clear and fair rules and incentives
- avoid excessive concentration
of power through appropriate checks and balances relevant and accurate information
- ensure accountability for
decisions and actions, which are based on comprehensive and reliable analysis
- encourage cooperation in order
to build trust and shared goals and values principle of subsidiarity where
possible.
Note: These techniques were published in a report
by the INternational Institute for Environment and Development ("Breaking
New Ground: Mining, Materials, and Sustainable Development) and have been
corroborated and revised by experts in the industry. These techniques
will be specified shortly.
Research done by Brendan
ECOTOURISM
Ecotourism can
be utilized at three main levels to help support
environmental protection and rehabilitation
in the Amazon Basin Rainforest.
- The most widespread,
easy to implament ecotourism is for the general consumer. That
is, making standard vacation packeges that are socially responsible,
but don't reduce luxary or relaxation. This will appeal to the
widest audience, but might not have a huge impact on the environment.
The main benifits are that increased tourism will be benificial to the
economy, areas that are being visited will not be pristene, but will
remain natural to some degree to attract the environmentally conscious
tourists, and the global level of knowledge about the rainforest and local
people will increase because of the greater exposure to the world.
- The are ideal for high
school age students and younger, though they can be attrative to older
people as well. This would be a blend between relaxing vacation
and service projects. Two ways that this could be effective are having
a stable group that leads consecutive trips with different groups to the
same area, or having the visiting students work with already active community
groups. Both methods could be sustainable. The benifits
of this type of ecotourism are that large projects can be funded and
accomplished, therefore reducing the strain on government funding for
restoration projects, and that students of a young age can learn about
the importance of the rainforest on the global community.
- The most indepth and restricted
level of ecotourism is long term research and community work.
This would be geered towards college students and researchers. In
this setting, people would stay for extended periods of time greater
than six months and work consistantly on a project. The benifits
of thie level are conduction of high level research that will greater expose
the area to the public view, consistant, funded work in an area or
on a project, and because at this level the participants are deeply
interested in the subject and have some level of expertese, they are able
to contribute to the knowledge of the region, possibly doing work with local
comminities with education, health and sustainable farming practices.
A successful plan
will encourage all of these aspects of ecotourism so
that the greatest number of people will be affected
and the widest range of conservation will be achieved.
Research done by Emma
AGRICULTURE
TERRA PRETA:
Scientists have lately been working on studying
and reproducing a type of rare soil found in the Amazon Basin which they
have named "terra preta." This soil, unlike most of the soils in the
Amazon, yields great productivity and long-lasting fertility. Furthermore,
it seems to actually be the product of previous intensive agricultural activity
in the Amazon. This indicates that some kind of sustainable, intensive agriculture
is possible in the Amazon.
Since there are some very specific materials that
are found in terra preta but not in normal oxisoils (the soil most common
to the Amazon), it is possible that a sort of package could be made of these
materials that could then simply be added to oxisoils to transform them
into terra preta.
Although terra preta needs to be managed carefully
and can bring its own complications with it, it could also have an extremely
beneficial effect on agriculture in the Amazon, both by increasing the yield
per unit acre (making it necessary to deforest less land) and by increasing
the amount of time for which one plot of land can be farmed (also making it
necessary to deforest less land). Also, when the plots of terra preta
are finally abandoned, the terra preta can still support some sort of vegetation,
so the forest can return more quickly.
source of above information: article by Charles
C. Mann called "The Real Dirt on Rainforest Fertility" which was published
online in Science
Magazine in 2002
AGROFORESTRY:
wide range of options which boil down to the idea
that
woody or herbaceous perennials are grown on land
that also
supports agricultural crops, animals, native species.
If well devised, such systems have many agronomic, environmental and socioeconomic
benefits for resource-poor small-scale farmers. Enhanced nutrient cycling,
fixing of nitrogen, efficient distribution of water and light (multistory
canopy and differnd depth of roots), conservation of soil, natural suppression
of weeds (by production of allelopathic compounds by perennials) and diversification
of farm products.
perennial tree crop plantations: harvest of timber
or tree products +
cycling of nutrients through roots + conservation
of soil + long-term investment on land (encourages more stability in the settlements)
+ harvest of natural products.
Agroforestry has a lot to gain from the knowlege
of the indigenous people who know how to model the forest in a profitable
way without hurting it. They do not make a clear distinction between wildlife
and domesticated life. Rather, they model their surrounding in a integrated
system which takes the best profit out of the ressources of the forest. Ecological
cycles are respected by allowing for buffer zones, sufficient fallows, regeneration
of the soil and weed and pest control by methods to us unknown which come
from centuries of trial and error and cohabitation with the forest.
Marion
is currently devising a plan for such a farm which
could serve as an experiment and then hopefully become a model for the sustainable
life of the inhabitants of the forest. Such practices are very promising but
they can only work if migration to the forest is slowed down, that is if
the issue of land reform is adressed. Small peasants are forced to migrate
to the forest because rich landlords own the land in the south and use it
as a speculative tool. The land in the south is much more fertile than the
land in the forest and a large amount of it is left uncultivated. Controlling
the use of land through the monitoring scheme of SIVAM could be a way
to help the implementation of the agrarian reform the government has had trouble
enforcing in the last ten years.
CATTLE RANCHING
Here are a few options for ranchers to improve
sustainability and profit:
- Keep cattle herds at
conservative rates for the land they're on - don't overburden the land and
it won't burn out as quickly.
- Rotation of land - don't let
the cattle entirely destroy the land their grazing on and move them
around in a controlled fashion fairly often.
- Incorporate trees in
pasture land - it doesn't have a negative effect on the cattle and
could even be a tiny step back to reforestation someday.
These are the
key ideas that could be utilized fairly easy by farmers, even on a
small scale. Some sort of government support could also really help
this program. There is the idea that we could move the ranchers out
of the rainforest entirely, but I do not believe that this is a very
practical idea. I think it would be hard to find somewhere else for them to
go and it would also be extremely hard to force people to move in a
non-totalitarian state.
Industrialized countries like the US really need
to crack downon labelling beef to force fast food and other companies to
admit where they buy their beef so consumers can make informed decisions
about what they are buying.
Research done by
Liz
INFRASTRUCTURE
The ideal system of transportation would have the most effective
and efficient modes of transport tailored to the commodities that they are
moving. For the Amazon rain forest, the extra consideration is that
one wants to minimize the environmental impact of all transportation systems.
With these criteria in mind, we have concluded that the following system
would work best for Brazil.
- For transportation of industrial commodities, i.e.
lumber, mineral ores, oil, agricultural products, finished products from
within the rain forest over long distances towards eastern factories and
ports, railroads may be better for the enviornment than roads. When
new roads are created or old roads are improved, there tends to be a period
of "spontaneous colonization, logging, mining, and land speculation that
is almost impossible for governments to control" (Laurence et. al., "The
Future of the Brazilian Amazon." Science Magazine). We hypothesize
that this effect would be eliminated or greatly reduced if railroads were
built instead of roads, because railroads are less inviting to pedestrian
or vehicle traffic.
- Citing successful implementation of this method elsewhere
in remote areas, i.e. Alaska, airfields at all the urbanized areas will provide
adequate transport for any citizens who wish to travel. They only take
a small piece out of the jungle, and the emissions from aircraft would be
less than that of all the vehicles on major highways driving back and forth.
Airplanes really are a form of mass transit, even though they are not
always thought of in that light.
- Within the urban areas in the Amazon, streets and roads
are a necessity, but we cannot emphasize enough how we would like to see
other modes of transportation in all other areas where it is feasible. Mass
transit, like busing, in the towns and cities would be a definite boon
to the environment by reducing emissions and reducing the number of vehicles,
which then reduces the need for more pavement, more vehicles, more emissions,
etc.
None of this is meant to sound
as though we wish to isolate those already living in the Amazon from the
rest of Brazil in favor of protecting the environment by simply not providing
them the transportation infrastructure that they so desperately want and
need. Our aim is to provide that transportation, but through alternative
methods, so as to still preserve the priceless environment and biodiversity
of the region.
HOME